How do crane makers answer a customer's specification?
Most cranes are built from a maker's standard range: a girder family, a hoist family, a control package. The customer's specification was written for a building and a process, not for your range. The sales engineer's work is to find each place where the two do not meet, and to decide whether to change the crane, raise the price or write a deviation.
| Subject | What the customer states | What to settle before you quote |
|---|---|---|
| Duty classification | A class or group for the crane and for each mechanism, or the working cycles and loads it is based on | Does the system the customer names match the one your calculations use? If only the process is described, who derives the class? |
| Capacity, span and lift | Rated capacity, span, height of lift, hook approaches, speeds and any second hoist | Is the capacity for the hook alone, or does it include a lifting beam, grab or magnet below it? |
| The building and runway | Runway rails, the clearances available, the power supply and the wheel loads the structure can take | Who supplies the runway, the rails and the conductor system, and who checks the building for your wheel loads? |
| Site standards | The plant's own rules for motors, cabling, panels, paint, access and guarding | Which site standards are in the package, and which are named but not attached? |
| Controls and safety functions | Control mode, limit switches, overload protection, anti-collision, zone restrictions and any required performance level for a safety function | Is each function in your standard package, an option or a one-off design? |
| Environment | Indoor or outdoor, temperature range, dust, corrosion, hazardous areas | Does any clause take the crane outside your standard components? |
| Tests | Works tests on the hoist, tests after erection, and who attends | Who provides the test loads on site, and is an overload test part of the handover? |
| Documentation requirements | The list of documents, the language, the format and when each is due | Which documents need approval before fabrication starts? |
Read the classification clause first and the documentation clause second. The first sets the steel and the machinery. The second sets the hours your office will spend after the crane is built. A customer who wants full calculations where you normally issue a summary has asked for something that needs a price or a deviation.
Which standards and rules come up in crane enquiries?
| Document | What it is | Where it bites |
|---|---|---|
| EN 13001 series | The European series for the general design of cranes: principles, load actions and proof of competence for structures and components | The structural and mechanical calculations behind a crane sold in Europe |
| EN 15011 | The European product standard for bridge and gantry cranes | The safety requirements for the finished crane, with the checks used to verify them |
| ISO 4301 | The ISO series on the classification of cranes and mechanisms by service conditions | The class the customer writes into the enquiry |
| FEM 1.001 | The European Materials Handling Federation's rules for the design of hoisting appliances | Older specifications and many hoist catalogues still state FEM groups |
| Machinery Directive and Machinery Regulation | The EU law for placing machinery, including lifting machinery and lifting accessories, on the market | Risk assessment, technical file, instructions, declaration of conformity and CE marking |
| ASME B30 series | The American safety standard for cranes, hoists, hooks, slings and related equipment, published in separate volumes by equipment type | North American enquiries name the volume for the equipment, such as the ones for overhead and gantry cranes, hoists or below-the-hook lifting devices |
| ASME BTH-1 | ASME's design standard for below-the-hook lifting devices | Design of lifting beams, spreaders and similar devices for the North American market |
| CMAA specifications | The Crane Manufacturers Association of America's specifications for electric overhead travelling cranes: No. 70 for multiple girder cranes and No. 74 for single girder cranes | North American enquiries state a service class and expect the crane to follow the specification |
| LOLER | The Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations 1998 in Great Britain | They bind the user, not the maker. They explain why a British buyer asks for certain documents |
Classification systems do not convert cleanly. An ISO class, a FEM group and a CMAA service class are built on different definitions, and published comparison charts are approximations. If the customer names one system and your range is rated in another, state the class you offer in the customer's system and say how you arrived at it. All of these standards are paid documents. This page gives their names and subjects, not their content.
What goes in a crane maker's deviation list?
A crane deviation list is rarely about whether the crane can lift the load. It is about how the customer wants it built and proved. The rows tend to fall under these headings.
- Classification: the customer asks for a higher class on one mechanism than your standard hoist carries, or names a classification system you do not design to.
- Design standard: the specification mixes families, for example a European crane standard with an American service class, and you state which one governs your calculations.
- Deflection, speeds and positioning: limits tighter than your standard girder or drive gives.
- Components: a named make of motor, brake, gearbox, drive, rope or pendant where you fit your own or another supplier's.
- Electrical and controls: site standards for cable types, enclosure ratings, panel layout, spare capacity or a safety function your control package does not include.
- Access and maintenance: walkways, platforms and service points beyond the standard arrangement.
- Materials and inspection: certificate types for load-bearing steel, extra NDE on girder welds, or witness points you do not normally offer.
- Testing: an overload test at a level or in a way that differs from your procedure, or test loads the customer expects you to supply.
- Documents: full calculations where you issue a summary, native drawing files, or approval of drawings before fabrication.
Each row should quote the clause and your alternative, with a reason. The layout is in the technical deviation list guide. Once the order is placed, the Deviation Register (beta) keeps the agreed rows in one place, so the design office works to the negotiated position.
Which documents does a crane maker deliver after award?
| Document | What it shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Calculation summary | The classification used, the load cases considered and the result for the main structure and mechanisms | A summary that states a different class from the one in the order |
| Material certificates for load-bearing parts | Grade and test results for girder plate, end carriages, hooks, ropes and lifting lugs | A hook or rope certificate whose serial number is not the one fitted. See EN 10204 3.1 vs 3.2 |
| Welding and NDE records | Procedures, welder qualifications and examination reports for the welds the specification picks out | Girder butt welds examined to a lower extent than the customer's clause |
| Load test certificate | The crane's identity, the loads applied, the tests carried out, the date and who witnessed them | A certificate for the hoist unit only, where the order asks for a test of the erected crane |
| Electrical test records | Insulation, protective bonding and function checks, including limit switches and emergency stop | Safety functions listed in the specification that the test sheet never mentions |
| Declaration of conformity | The maker's formal statement that the machine meets the law that applies, with the standards used | A declaration that describes a different model or rated capacity |
| Instructions | Operation, maintenance, inspection intervals and limits of use, in the language required | A generic manual that does not cover the options fitted |
| Documents for the user's examination regime | The information a competent person needs: identity, safe working load, configuration, test results and the maker's inspection guidance | Marking on the crane that does not match the paperwork |
A crane is often tested twice: the hoist in the works, and the whole crane after erection on the customer's runway. The second test depends on someone else's building. Say in the offer which tests you do where, and which certificate covers each. Buyers in Great Britain will also arrange a thorough examination after installation, and their examiner will ask for your documents. The load test certificate checklist lists the fields worth checking before the certificate leaves your office.
How does OdysseyGPT help?
OdysseyGPT compares one set of documents with another and shows the words behind every finding. For a crane maker that means the customer's specification on one side and your standard specification, offer or records on the other. An engineer reads each finding and decides. It works on text and tables. It does not open general arrangement drawings, and it does no calculation.
| Stage | You upload | Tool | You get |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enquiry | The crane specification and site standards, with your standard technical specification | Document Review | Each customer requirement set beside your statement on it, marked as complies, deviates, not addressed or needing clarification |
| Enquiry | The customer's package on its own | Customer Specification Review (beta) | A list of requirements by type, with gaps flagged, such as a site standard that is named and not attached |
| Order | The specification, your offer and the clarification letters | Deviation Register (beta) | One register of the agreed deviations |
| Order | The customer's document list and the order's documentation clauses | VDRL/MDR Tracker (beta) | A register of every document owed, with late and missing items flagged |
| Manufacture | The customer's quality requirements and your inspection and test plan | ITP Validator (beta) | Inspection stages the plan omits and witness points shown at a lower level |
| Manufacture | Certificates for plate, hooks and ropes, with the purchase requirements | Material Certificate Review (beta) | Grades, certificate types and required tests that do not match the order |
| Manufacture | Welding procedures, welder records and the weld list as a table | Welding Qualification Review (beta) | Welds outside a procedure's range and welders without a valid qualification on the day |
| Manufacture | The weld list and the NDE reports | NDE Coverage Review (beta) | Welds that need examination and have no report, or the wrong method |
| Before the test | The test procedure, the plan, calibration evidence and the open non-conformance list | FAT Readiness Check (beta) | What would stop the test, kept apart from items to review |
| After the test | Test reports and the calibration certificates for load cells and instruments | Calibration Validity Check (beta) | Instruments on a test report with no certificate, or a certificate that had expired on the test date |
| Handover | The customer's document index and your document folder | MRB Readiness Check (beta) | Index lines with nothing behind them and documents at an old revision |
The load test certificate itself has no dedicated check. Document Review can compare its stated capacity, identity and test description with the order and the test procedure, and report where the wording differs. It cannot tell you whether the test was done properly.
What does a result look like for a crane enquiry?
This example is invented. The specification number, clause numbers, crane data and document names were made up for this page. It shows the layout of a Document Review result.
| Customer requirement (quoted) | Maker's document (quoted) | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| §3.1, p. 5: "Rated capacity 20 t at the hook. Span 22.5 m." | §2.1, p. 3: "Rated capacity: 20 t. Span: 22.5 m." | Complies | Same capacity and span. |
| §3.4, p. 6: "Hoist mechanism classification shall be M6 to ISO 4301-1." | §2.3, p. 4: "Hoist mechanism group: M5." | Deviates | The standard hoist is stated one group below the class asked for. |
| §5.2, p. 11: "All motors shall comply with site standard ES-MOT-03." | §4.1, p. 8: "Motors to manufacturer's standard, IP55." | Clarification | ES-MOT-03 is not in the package. Ask the customer for it. |
| §6.3, p. 14: "An anti-collision system shall prevent contact with the adjacent crane on the same runway." | No matching statement found. | Not addressed | The standard specification does not mention anti-collision. |
| §7.1, p. 16: "Girder butt welds shall be 100% ultrasonically examined." | §6.2, p. 12: "Butt welds in tension flanges: ultrasonic examination, 10% sample." | Deviates | The sample extent is lower than the full examination asked for. |
| §8.2, p. 19: "After erection the crane shall be load tested in the presence of the purchaser. The supplier shall provide test loads." | §7.4, p. 15: "Site load test with test loads provided by the purchaser." | Deviates | The two documents place the supply of test loads on different parties. |
| §9.1, p. 21: "Documentation shall include the structural calculations for the bridge girders." | §8.1, p. 17: "A calculation summary is supplied with the documentation." | Clarification | A summary may not satisfy a request for the calculations. Confirm what the customer will accept. |
| §9.4, p. 22: "Operating and maintenance instructions shall be in English." | §8.3, p. 17: "Instructions are supplied in English." | Complies | Same language. |
Each row carries the clause and page on both sides, so the sales engineer can check it in a minute. The status is a proposal. Whether a row becomes a deviation, a price addition or a design change is your decision.
Where OdysseyGPT falls short
- It does no crane design. It does not classify a crane, calculate a girder, select a rope or check a design against EN 13001, CMAA or any other standard.
- It does not read general arrangement drawings, clearance diagrams or electrical schematics. Data on a drawing has to reach it as text or a table.
- It does not perform or witness a load test, and it cannot confirm that a test was carried out as the certificate says.
- It does not carry out a thorough examination and is not a competent person under LOLER.
- It does not assess a safety function or its performance level, and it does not replace your risk assessment.
- It does not issue or validate a declaration of conformity or a CE or UKCA mark. It can report what a declaration says against what the order says.
- It sees only what you upload. If a site standard is named in the specification and missing from the package, it will say so and cannot check against it.
- A fair trial is an enquiry you have already answered: run it and compare the result with the deviation list you wrote by hand.
Which tools are available now
Document Review is generally available. The other tools named on this page are in beta: you ask for access and we set each team up ourselves. See the tender module and OdysseyGPT for manufacturing.
Talk through your tender review
See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender
Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.
