OdysseyGPT

Bid engineering checklist

How to check a valve, pump or instrument datasheet against a client specification: a 25-point checklist

A practical vendor document review for the engineer who has to confirm, line by line, that the datasheet you are about to submit matches what the client asked for.

By Ademola Afolabi, Founder, New Odyssey Ltd · Last reviewed:

The short answer

To check a datasheet against a client specification, list every governing document and its revision. Then compare the datasheet line by line for service conditions, design standard, rating, materials, tests, certificates, accessories and documents. Record each mismatch as a deviation or clarification with the clause, the offered value and a justification.

Key Takeaways

  • Start with the documents and revisions, not the datasheet: most misses come from checking against the wrong issue.
  • Compare values in the specification's own units and terms.
  • Materials, tests and certificates are where costly deviations hide.
  • Every mismatch becomes a row in the deviation list with a clause reference.

Why datasheet review takes so long

A datasheet looks short, but each line points to a specification clause, an owner standard or a referenced code. In one vendor case study, a large EPC spent 15 to 20 minutes per datasheet review just extracting the data, across roughly 150 vendor RFPs that included valve datasheets (Botminds). Checking each value against the specification takes longer than that.

Manufacturers feel the same load from the other side. One proposal engineer job advert lists "Review and analyze RFQ, RFP, ITP and related tender documents" and "Identify technical risks, assumptions, and deviations" among the duties (Kowork). The checklist below is the order we suggest for doing that work.

The 25-point checklist

Datasheet vs client specification: 25 checks for valves, pumps and instruments
#CheckWhat to compareApplies to
1Document list and revisionsRequisition, project spec, owner standards, datasheets and addenda: is every one present, at the latest issue?All
2Order of precedenceWhich document wins when two disagree. Raise a TQ if the requisition does not say. See governing-document precedence.All
3Tag numbers and quantitiesEvery tag on the requisition has a datasheet, and quantities match.All
4Service conditionsFluid, operating and design pressure and temperature, flow, and any sour, cryogenic or abrasive service.All
5Design standard and editionProduct standard named in the spec (for example API 6D, API 610 or a measurement standard) and the edition.All
6Pressure class and ratingASME class or PN, and that the rating covers the design pressure at design temperature.Valves, pumps
7Size and end connectionsNominal size, bore, flange facing and finish, or weld-end preparation.Valves, pumps
8Face-to-face or dimensionsFace-to-face length or installation dimensions against the standard the spec cites.Valves, instruments
9Body and pressure-part materialsMaterial grade and form (cast or forged) against the material requirement.All
10Trim, internals and wetted partsSeats, stem, trim, impeller or sensor materials, and coatings or hardfacing.All
11Bolting and gasketsBolting grade, coating and gasket type.Valves, pumps
12Sour-service and corrosion requirementsNACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 or the owner's equivalent, including hardness limits.All
13Low- or high-temperature requirementsImpact testing, extended bonnets, cryogenic testing.Valves
14Operator or actuatorGear, actuator type, sizing basis, fail position, torque margins.Valves
15Seals and emissionsStem seal or mechanical seal design, and fugitive-emission class such as ISO 15848-1.Valves, pumps
16Fire-safe designFire test standard named in the spec and the certificate offered.Valves
17Pressure and performance testsShell, seat, hydrostatic and performance tests, and which standard they follow. For pumps, also the NPSH margin, performance curves and guaranteed vibration limits (What Is Piping).All
18Material certificatesCertificate type such as EN 10204 3.1 or 3.2 and which parts need it.All
19Inspection and witness pointsHold and witness points in the inspection and test plan.All
20Electrical and hazardous areaArea classification, protection concept, ingress protection and power supply.Instruments, actuators, motors
21Signals and accuracyOutput signal, communication protocol, range, accuracy and calibration requirements.Instruments
22Painting and coatingPaint system and colour against the client's painting spec.All
23Accessories and scopeLimit switches, positioners, baseplates, couplings, spares: offered or excluded.All
24DocumentationItems in the vendor data requirements list and their submission dates.All
25Marking, packing and preservationNameplate data, tagging, packing and long-term storage requirements.All

Sample deviation rows from a datasheet check

Each mismatch found by the checklist becomes one row in your technical deviation list. The rows below are invented to show the format.

Illustrative rows (invented specifications PS-INS-007 and PS-VAL-001)
Check #Spec clauseRequirementOfferedStatusJustificationCost of withdrawal
6PS-VAL-001 §3.2ASME Class 600ASME Class 600CompliesDatasheet line 6None
12PS-VAL-001 §4.8Wetted parts to NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156Body and trim to NACE MR0175; bolting standard gradeDeviationBolting is not exposed to the process; sour-service bolting available+2% unit price
18PS-VAL-001 §7.2EN 10204 3.2 for body and bonnetEN 10204 3.1DeviationMaterial tested by our inspection department; 3.2 needs third-party validation+3%, +2 weeks, inspector fees by buyer
20PS-INS-007 §5.1Ex d IIC T4 transmitter housingEx d IIB T4DeviationGas group in the area classification drawing is IIB; buyer to confirmIIC housing: +USD 180 per unit
21PS-INS-007 §6.3HART 7 output4-20 mA with HART 7CompliesDatasheet line 14None
24PS-INS-007 §9.1Calibration certificate within 10 days of shipmentCalibration certificate shipped with the instrumentClarificationCertificate dated at final test; confirm acceptableNone

Valve, pump and instrument differences

EquipmentPlaces worth a second lookRelated page
ValvesMaterial form (cast vs forged), fire test, fugitive emissions, certificates, actuator sizingAPI valve standards
PumpsSeal plan, materials class, performance test witness, driver scopeEngineering compliance matrix
InstrumentsHazardous-area rating, accuracy, communication protocol, calibrationTemplates

Doing the check faster

Work from a compliance matrix template so every check above has a row, and filter it into the deviation list at the end. OdysseyGPT checks each customer requirement against your own datasheets. It gives each one a status with a quote from the source page, sheet or cell. Then it exports an editable compliance matrix and deviations & clarifications list. Your engineers decide every open item. It reads PDF, Word, Excel and CSV files, and it does not interpret engineering drawings such as general arrangements or P&IDs. See OdysseyGPT for manufacturing.

Buyer questions

20 questions bid engineers, proposal engineers and buyers ask. Last reviewed:

What is an equipment datasheet in a tender?

An equipment datasheet is a short table that fixes the key data for one item or tag: service conditions, design standard, rating, size, materials, tests and accessories. The buyer issues it with the requirements filled in. The manufacturer completes or returns it with what it offers. It sits beside the project specification, which holds the longer written requirements.

Who fills in the vendor side of a datasheet?

The manufacturer's bid engineer, proposal engineer or project manager usually fills in the vendor side. They take values from the product design, catalogue and qualification records. Many client datasheets mark some fields for the vendor to complete, such as weight, model number or torque. A second engineer should check the finished sheet before it goes out with the offer.

If the datasheet and the specification disagree, which one wins?

The order of precedence in the requisition decides. Many requisitions rank the datasheet above the general specification, but not all do, so read the actual wording. If no order is given, or the conflict matters to price or design, raise a technical query before you bid. See governing-document precedence.

What should I do with blank or 'by vendor' fields on a client datasheet?

Fill every 'by vendor' field with a real value, not a dash. For fields the client left blank that affect design, such as a missing design temperature, state the value you assumed. Then list it as a clarification in your deviation list. An empty field gives the evaluator a question to send back, and slows your bid down.

Should I convert units on the datasheet to my own?

No. Answer in the units and terms the client used, such as barg, degrees Celsius or ASME class. If your design data is in other units, convert it and keep your own value in brackets where that helps. Evaluators compare values side by side, and a conversion they must do themselves is a chance for a misread.

How do I know I am checking the right datasheet revision?

Start from the document list in the requisition and any addenda issued since. Each names the datasheet number and revision that applies. Check the revision block on the sheet itself, including revision clouds or triangles that mark changed values. If two revisions are in the package, confirm in writing which one governs before you complete it.

Why do design and operating conditions both matter on a datasheet?

Operating conditions describe normal service; design conditions set what the equipment must be rated for. Ratings, materials and wall thickness follow the design values. Performance, such as pump flow or valve sizing, often follows the operating values. Check both against your offer, and check the upset or minimum temperature too, because it can drive impact testing.

Why does cast versus forged matter on a valve datasheet?

Many specifications state the product form for pressure parts, not just the grade. A cast body offered where forged is required is a deviation, even if the chemistry is similar. Forgings and castings are covered by different material specifications and need different inspection. Check the form on your material list against the datasheet and the piping class.

Should a datasheet state the edition of the design standard?

Yes, where the tender names one or the edition affects design or testing. Product standards change between editions, and evaluators check that the edition you build to matches the one called up. If the tender says latest edition, state the edition you offer as a clarification. That removes doubt before award, not after.

Do the notes on a datasheet count as requirements?

Yes. Notes at the foot of a datasheet often carry requirements that are not in the main table, such as extra tests, coatings, special cleaning or witness points. Treat each note as its own requirement in your compliance matrix. Missed notes are a common source of late deviations found after the order is placed.

How do I check a datasheet that covers many tags?

Split it into one row per tag and per value that differs. A multi-tag sheet often shares most data but changes size, rating, fluid or fail position by tag. Check that every tag on the requisition has a column or sheet, and that quantities match. Then compare each tag on its own, not just the first column.

Can I send a catalogue instead of filling in the datasheet?

Usually not. Most tenders ask for the client datasheet to be completed, and a catalogue does not show which option you are offering. Send the completed datasheet and attach the catalogue or product data as supporting evidence. Make sure the catalogue does not contradict the datasheet, because evaluators read both.

How does a datasheet check turn into a deviation list?

Each value you check becomes a row with a status. Rows that comply stay in your compliance matrix. Rows that do not comply, or need a clarification, move to the technical deviation list with the clause, the offered value, a justification and the cost of withdrawal.

What do EPC evaluators look for first on a vendor datasheet?

Evaluators usually start with the values that decide whether the offer is technically acceptable. These are design standard, rating, materials, tests and certificates, then scope and accessories. They compare each one with the requisition issue that applies. A clear datasheet with values in the client's terms, and a matching deviation list, lets them move on quickly. See technical bid evaluation.

Is there a standard format for a pump datasheet?

Many centrifugal pump tenders use the datasheet forms that come with API 610, or an owner's version of them. Other tenders use the EPC's own template. Either way, check which form and revision the tender asks for, and fill in every field the form leaves to the vendor. See the API 610 datasheet guide for pump-specific checks.

What is different about checking an instrument datasheet?

Instrument datasheets carry more electrical and signal data than valve or pump sheets. Check the hazardous-area rating, ingress protection, power supply, output signal and protocol, range, accuracy and calibration. Also check process connection and wetted materials. Small mismatches in gas group or temperature class are easy to miss and costly to change later.

Who should check a vendor datasheet before it is submitted?

A second engineer who did not fill it in should check it. They should focus on materials, tests, certificates and any value marked as a deviation. Where the tender includes specialist items, such as sour service or hazardous areas, ask the relevant specialist to look at those lines. Record the check so you can show who reviewed what.

Does the datasheet change after the order is placed?

Often, yes. After award the vendor datasheet is usually reissued for the buyer's review, as one of the documents on the vendor data requirements list. Agreed deviations and clarifications should be built into that issue. A final, as-built datasheet is often part of the end-of-job documentation.

How does OdysseyGPT check a datasheet against the specification?

OdysseyGPT reads the tender package, including specifications, the requisition and datasheets. It checks each customer requirement against your own datasheets, standard specifications and test procedures. Each requirement gets a status, such as complies, deviates or clarification, with a quote and the page, sheet or cell it came from. You export an editable compliance matrix and deviation list.

What can OdysseyGPT not check on a datasheet?

It does not interpret engineering drawings such as general arrangements or P&IDs. It can only check what a standard says if that text is in the documents you upload, and it does not certify compliance. It also cannot know a client's unwritten preferences. Your engineers review every status, decide open items and own what is sent to the customer.

Frequently asked questions

What is a vendor document?

A vendor document is any document the supplier submits about its equipment, such as datasheets, drawings, calculations, test procedures, certificates and manuals. The vendor data requirements list says which ones are due and when.

What is the difference between a project datasheet and a vendor datasheet?

The project datasheet is issued by the buyer and states what is required. The vendor datasheet is completed by the manufacturer and states what is offered. Reviewing one against the other is the core of datasheet review.

Which datasheet checks find the most expensive deviations?

Materials, tests and certificates, because changing them after award usually means new material, extra testing or third-party inspection. Check them twice.

Should I record checks where the datasheet complies?

Yes in your own compliance matrix, so you can show nothing was skipped. The deviation list you submit carries only the rows that do not comply.

References

RFP presales abstraction case study

Botminds

Vendor case study

Visit source

Proposal engineer job advert

Kowork

Visit source

Technical bid evaluation: guide for vendor offer review

What Is Piping

Visit source

Related Pages