How do food and beverage equipment makers answer a customer specification?
A dairy, brewery, soft drinks bottler or food producer rarely sends one document. The enquiry for a mixing tank, a plate heat exchanger skid or a filler normally arrives as a set, and each part of the set asks for different things.
| Document | What it sets | Where the surprises sit |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate engineering standard | Materials, welding, pipework, electrical and automation rules that apply to every supplier on every site | Written for all equipment types, so many clauses do not fit your machine and nobody says which |
| Hygienic design standard | The producer's own rules for product-contact and splash areas, often built on EHEDG guidelines or 3-A documents | Finish, radius, seal and drainage rules stricter than the guideline it cites |
| User requirement specification | Capacity, products, viscosities, temperatures, changeover times and the utilities on site | Product and cleaning conditions that rule out your standard seal or gasket material |
| Preferred component list | Named makes for valves, pumps, instruments, seals and drives, so the site holds one set of spares | A named make you do not normally fit, with a longer lead time or a different hygienic connection |
| Cleaning requirements | Whether the item is cleaned in place or stripped down, the detergents, temperatures and flow the site's cleaning station can give | A cleaning regime your elastomers, spray devices or pump seals were not selected for |
| Documentation requirements | The certificates, declarations, records and manuals wanted, and the dossier format | Declarations for every seal and hose, in the customer's own form |
The job at quotation is to turn that set into rows. Each row carries one requirement, the clause it came from, what you offer and a status. Requirements that do not apply to your scope still get a row, marked not applicable with a reason, so the customer can see the clause was read.
- Split the product-contact scope from the rest. Most hygienic clauses apply to surfaces that touch product, and the cost of applying them to frames, guards and utilities is large.
- Write down the cleaning method for each item in your scope: clean in place, cleaned out of place, or manual. Finish, seal and drainage clauses often depend on it.
- Compare each hygienic clause with your fabrication standard and the datasheets of the components you plan to fit.
- Check the preferred component list against your bill of materials, line by line.
- List the documents asked for and mark the ones you must collect from your own suppliers.
- Mark every row complies, deviates, clarification or not addressed, and write the reason.
The result is a compliance matrix covering every clause, and a technical deviation list carrying only the differences. A blank hygienic design requirement checklist is a useful start for the hygienic clauses.
Which standards and rules come up in food equipment specifications?
Customer standards cite a mix of voluntary guidelines, European machinery standards and food contact law. The table names the ones that appear most often and what each is. It is our own summary at name level. Use the edition or version your contract names.
| Document | What it is | What the specification usually asks you to show |
|---|---|---|
| EHEDG guidelines | Numbered guidance documents from the European Hygienic Engineering & Design Group, covering general hygienic design principles and specific equipment such as valves, pumps, tanks and conveyors | That the design follows named guidelines, or that named components hold an EHEDG certificate of a stated type and class |
| 3-A Sanitary Standards | Design and fabrication criteria for dairy and food equipment published by 3-A Sanitary Standards, Inc. in the United States | That equipment or components are authorised to carry the 3-A Symbol, or are built to a named 3-A document |
| EN 1672-2 | The European standard on hygiene and cleanability requirements for food processing machinery | A statement of conformity, usually as part of the machinery documentation |
| EN ISO 14159 | The standard on hygiene requirements for the design of machinery | The same, where the customer's standard cites it beside or in place of EN 1672-2 |
| Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004 | The European framework regulation on materials and articles intended to come into contact with food. Great Britain applies its own assimilated version | A written declaration for each product-contact material, and traceability of those materials |
| Regulation (EC) No 2023/2006 and Regulation (EU) No 10/2011 | The good manufacturing practice regulation for food contact materials, and the specific measure for plastics | Declarations of compliance for plastic parts such as hoses, belts, scrapers and sight glasses |
| FDA 21 CFR | Title 21 of the US Code of Federal Regulations. The food contact sections sit in the parts on indirect food additives, such as Part 177 on polymers | A supplier statement naming the section each elastomer or polymer complies with |
| EN 10204 | The European standard that defines types of inspection document for metallic products | A type 3.1 inspection certificate for stainless steel in contact with product |
Two points are worth settling early. EHEDG and 3-A are voluntary schemes. They bind you when the order cites them, and the order may cite one, both or the customer's own blend. The food contact regulations are law for materials placed on the relevant market, whatever the order says.
Stainless steel and rubber have no single European measure
The European Commission lists specific measures for plastics, ceramics, regenerated cellulose film and a few other groups. It lists none that covers metals in general, and for rubber only a narrow one on teats and soothers. Where no specific measure exists, national rules may apply. Ask the customer which national rule or guidance its declaration form expects for metals and elastomers.
What goes in the deviation list for food processing equipment?
A hygienic design standard is written once for a whole company, and your equipment is one item in it. Most offers therefore carry a short list of honest differences. These are the areas where they usually fall.
| Area | What to check before you sign the offer |
|---|---|
| Surface finish | The roughness limit for product-contact surfaces, whether it also applies to welds, whether a named finish such as electropolish is asked for, and how the customer wants it measured and recorded |
| Weld finish | Whether welds are to be ground flush, left as welded, or polished to match the parent surface, and the acceptance wording for discolouration and inside tube welds |
| Elastomer grades | The seal and gasket materials named, the declarations wanted for each, and whether they suit the customer's products, detergents and temperatures |
| Drainability | Slope of pipework and tank bottoms, self-draining pumps and valves, and whether the customer wants this shown on a drawing or proved by a test |
| Dead ends and crevices | Limits on branch length, instrument pockets and threaded or metal-to-metal joints in the product zone |
| Component brands | Named makes on the preferred component list against the makes you normally fit, including the hygienic connection standard |
| Certified components | Whether valves, pumps and sensors must hold an EHEDG certificate or 3-A Symbol authorisation, and for which class or cleaning method |
| Cleaning | Flow, temperature and chemical limits of your equipment against the site's cleaning station, and who supplies spray devices and return pumps |
| Documents | The number of declarations, certificates and records asked for, and whether the customer's forms replace your own |
Write each deviation with the clause, what you offer and the reason. "Supplier standard" is not a reason. "Bought-in valve is supplied with the maker's standard finish, as stated on its datasheet" is one the customer can accept or reject.
A named guideline is not a finish value
A clause that says "surfaces in accordance with EHEDG" does not tell you which guideline, which version or which surfaces. Ask. Do not copy a roughness figure from memory into your offer: read it in the document the contract names.
Which documents follow after award?
After the order the customer's documentation clause becomes a list of submissions. The contract decides the list. A maker of tanks, skids or fillers for a food plant should expect most of these.
| Document | What the customer looks for |
|---|---|
| Material certificates for product-contact parts | An EN 10204 certificate of the type ordered for each sheet, tube, fitting and bar in contact with product, with the grade and heat number readable |
| Food contact declarations of compliance | One declaration for each seal, gasket, hose, belt and plastic part, naming the material, the regulation and any limits on food type, time and temperature |
| Surface finish records | Roughness measurements for the surfaces the specification names, with the instrument, the location of each reading and the limit it was judged against |
| Weld records, where specified | A weld list or map, the procedure and welder for each weld, and inspection results such as visual or borescope examination of tube welds |
| Passivation or pickling records, where specified | The treatment used, the date, and the areas treated |
| Component certificates | EHEDG certificates or 3-A Symbol authorisations for the components the order requires them for, still in date and matching the model fitted |
| Factory acceptance test record | The signed test record and punch list, including any cleanability, spray coverage or drainage test the order asks for. See FAT vs SAT |
| Machinery documents | The declaration of conformity or incorporation, the manual, and cleaning instructions that state the method the equipment was designed for |
| Documentation dossier | All of the above in the customer's index order, at the approved revision |
The declarations are the slow item. Each one comes from a component supplier, and some suppliers issue them only against a part number and batch. Ask for them with the purchase order for the part, not at the end of the build. The MTR review checklist covers the steel certificates.
How does OdysseyGPT help?
OdysseyGPT compares written documents. You upload the customer's requirements and your own documents, and each finding shows the two passages it rests on. Document Review takes the engineering standard, hygienic design standard and user requirements as the base and your datasheets, fabrication standard and quality plan as the answer. The other tools each read one type of record.
| Your document | Tool | What it reports |
|---|---|---|
| Customer engineering and hygienic design standards, and your offer documents | Document Review | A status and two quotes for each customer requirement, and statements in your documents the customer's text does not cover |
| Hygienic design standard, user requirements and cleaning requirements | Customer Specification Review (beta) | A register with one line per obligation on finish, seals, drainage, components and documents, each with its clause, plus wording flagged as unclear |
| The customer's equipment datasheet and your filled copy | Datasheet Comparison (beta) | Fields matched between the two sheets and each difference in value, with the cell it came from |
| Your offer, deviation list and the replies to clarification questions | Deviation Register (beta) | A single record of each deviation from first mention to the customer's decision |
| Stainless steel certificates for product-contact parts | Material Certificate Review (beta) | Grade, heat identity, chemistry, mechanical results and EN 10204 type for each certificate, set against the purchase requirements |
| Bill of materials, heat list and certificates | Material Traceability Check (beta) | Product-contact parts with no certificate behind them, and certificates that cover no listed part |
| Welding procedures, welder records and the weld list | Welding Qualification Review (beta) | Welds whose procedure or welder qualification does not cover them, where the order asks for weld records |
| Your inspection and test plan and the customer's quality clauses | ITP Validator (beta) | Inspections the customer asks for that the plan leaves out, and hold or witness points that differ |
| FAT procedure, approved drawings list, calibration certificates and punch list | FAT Readiness Check (beta) | Whether the paperwork a witnessed test depends on is in place, with blockers listed apart from review items |
| Dossier folder and the customer's index | MRB Readiness Check (beta) and MRB Compiler (beta) | Index entries that are missing, unapproved or at the wrong revision, and a manifest in the customer's order |
Food contact declarations and surface finish records have no dedicated tool. You can run them through Document Review against the customer's documentation clause, which shows what each declaration states beside what the clause asks for. The tools are grouped by stage: tender, manufacturing, inspection and handover.
What does a result look like?
The table below is an invented example. The dairy, the tank, the clause numbers, the maker's documents and every figure were made up to show how a result is laid out. Nothing in it is taken from a real customer, a real manufacturer, a guideline or a standard, and the figures are not recommended values.
| Customer requirement (quoted) | Maker's document (quoted) | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Product-contact parts shall be stainless steel 1.4404 with EN 10204 3.1 certificates." (HDS-02, 4.1) | "Wetted parts: 1.4404 (316L). Certificates to EN 10204 3.1 supplied for shell, heads, nozzles and agitator shaft." (Tank datasheet TD-118, p. 2) | Complies | Grade and certificate type match. Fittings are not named in the maker's list of certified parts. |
| "Product-contact surfaces, including welds, shall have a roughness not greater than Ra 0.5 µm." (HDS-02, 5.2) | "Internal finish: Ra ≤ 0.6 µm on sheet. Welds ground and brushed." (Fabrication standard FS-07, 3.4) | Deviates | The maker's limit is higher, and no roughness figure is given for welds. |
| "All elastomers in contact with product shall be EPDM with declarations to Regulation (EC) 1935/2004 and FDA 21 CFR 177.2600." (HDS-02, 6.3) | "Manway gasket: silicone. Agitator seal elastomers: EPDM." (Tank datasheet TD-118, p. 3) | Deviates | The manway gasket is a different material. No declarations are mentioned for either. |
| "Vessels shall be fully self-draining through the outlet valve." (HDS-02, 7.1) | "Bottom head: dished, centre outlet DN 65." (Tank datasheet TD-118, p. 2) | Clarification | The maker's text gives the shape and outlet but makes no statement on draining. |
| "Valves shall be of the make listed in the Preferred Component List and hold a valid EHEDG certificate." (HDS-02, 8.2) | "Outlet valve: hygienic butterfly valve, maker's standard supply." (Offer scope list, item 14) | Clarification | Neither the make nor a certificate is stated. |
| "Spray device coverage shall be demonstrated by a riboflavin test at the FAT." (URS-MT-01, 9.4) | No matching statement found in the documents supplied. | Not addressed | The maker's FAT procedure lists a water run and agitator test only. |
| "Tube welds in product lines shall be orbital welded and 10 % examined by borescope, with a weld log." (HDS-02, 5.6) | "Tube welds: orbital TIG where access allows. Visual inspection of external weld surface." (Quality plan QP-03, p. 5) | Deviates | No internal examination and no weld log are offered. |
| "The supplier shall provide a documentation dossier in the index order of Annex D, two weeks before dispatch." (HDS-02, 11.1) | "Final documentation is issued with the equipment." (Quality plan QP-03, p. 9) | Deviates | Timing differs, and the maker's text does not mention the customer's index. |
An engineer reads both quotes on each row and keeps or changes the status. The fourth row shows the limit of a document check: whether the tank drains is a matter for the drawing and the tank, and the tool can only report that the datasheet is silent.
Where OdysseyGPT falls short
- It does not assess hygienic design. It cannot tell you whether a tank, a seal arrangement or a conveyor frame is cleanable, only what your documents say about it.
- It does not read general arrangement drawings, P&IDs, isometrics or weld details. A slope, a radius or a dead end that appears only on a drawing is not checked.
- It does not test anything. It runs no cleanability, spray coverage or drainage test and takes no roughness measurement.
- It does not certify equipment and has no link to EHEDG, 3-A SSI or any test laboratory. It cannot confirm that a certificate is genuine or still listed: check the scheme's own register.
- It holds no guidelines or standards. A limit that sits only inside an EHEDG document, a 3-A document or EN 1672-2 is checked only if you upload the text your contract names and it is readable.
- It does not judge whether a seal material suits a product, a detergent or a temperature. It can show that the declaration states a limit and the specification states a duty.
- It can pair a requirement with the wrong passage or miss one, most often where a corporate standard repeats similar clauses for different zones. The quotes are there so a person can catch it.
- Tools shown with a beta marker on this page are available on request, and we set each team up ourselves.
Talk through your tender review
See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender
Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.
