OdysseyGPT

Free template

Hygienic design checklist: answering a customer's hygienic design requirements (Excel and CSV)

For food and beverage equipment suppliers: one row per requirement area, with the customer's clause, what you offer, a status and the document that proves it.

By Ademola Afolabi, Founder, New Odyssey Ltd · Last reviewed:

The short answer

A hygienic design checklist sets a food or beverage customer's hygienic design requirements beside what the supplier offers. This free Excel template has one row per area: product-contact materials, surface and weld finish, drainability, dead legs, seals, fasteners, cleaning, lubricants and documentation. Each row carries the customer's clause, a status and the evidence document.

Key Takeaways

  • The requirement column holds the customer's wording. The template states no roughness, slope or dead-leg figure.
  • Go through bought-in pumps, valves and instruments one at a time; an offer most often falls short there.
  • A Complies row is finished only when it names an evidence document.
  • The example has 12 rows for an invented dairy enquiry (RFQ-EX-6410), with three deviations and four clarifications.

Download the hygienic design checklist

Both files are free under CC BY 4.0, with no form to fill in. The XLSX opens in Excel, Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. The CSV carries the table only; the header block is in the XLSX.

When a customer sends a hygienic design specification

Food, dairy and beverage producers usually attach their own hygienic design specification to an enquiry. It draws on published guidance, often the EHEDG guidelines or 3-A Sanitary Standards, and for some equipment ASME BPE, but the figures that bind you are the ones the customer wrote down. This checklist is a short, structured answer to that document. It makes you look at each subject in turn across the whole scope of supply, and it shows the customer where you differ before the order is placed, not at the acceptance test.

  • Proposal and application engineers, who fill it in with the offer.
  • Design engineers, who check the offered column against the drawings.
  • The customer's hygiene or quality engineer, who will read the deviations and clarifications first.

For a full clause-by-clause answer, use the compliance matrix template; this checklist is the hygienic part of that work, grouped by subject. For background, see hygienic design and food processing equipment manufacturers.

Header block

Header block fields, with the invented example values
FieldExample
ProjectExample Dairy Filling Line (fictional)
CustomerExample Dairy Ltd (fictional)
Enquiry no.RFQ-EX-6410
Customer's hygienic design specificationHDS-EX-02 Rev 1 (invented)
Guidelines and standards the customer namesAs listed in HDS-EX-02 section 2, with their editions
Equipment offeredMixing tank skid with agitator, pump and pipework (fictional)
Offer no.OF-EX-6410 Rev A
Checklist no.HDC-EX-6410
Date2027-03-22
Prepared byProposal engineer
Checked byDesign engineer

Example rows: a mixing tank skid for a dairy

Invented example rows for enquiry RFQ-EX-6410
ItemRequirement areaCustomer clauseWhat the customer specifiesWhat is offeredStatusEvidence documentRemark
1Guidelines and editionsHDS-EX-02 2.1Design to the guidelines and standards listed in section 2Offer is based on the documents listed; two are listed without an editionClarificationOffer OF-EX-6410 section 3Ask the customer which editions apply, and state the editions the offer assumes.
2Product-contact materialsHDS-EX-02 3.1Product-contact metal parts in the stainless steel grade named in clause 3.1Grade as specified for tank, agitator, pipework and pump wetted partsCompliesMaterials list ML-EX-6410 Rev A
3Material certificatesHDS-EX-02 3.2Material certificates of the type named in clause 3.2 for all product-contact partsAs specified for tank and pipework. The pump maker's standard certificate is a different typeClarificationPump quotation PQ-EX-118Ask whether the pump maker's certificate type is accepted. The specified type is a priced option.
4Surface finishHDS-EX-02 4.1Product-contact surface roughness as specified by the customer in clause 4.1, with measurement recordsFinish as specified on tank internals and pipework, measured and recorded at the points the customer's clause namesCompliesSurface finish procedure SF-EX-01 Rev B
5Weld finishHDS-EX-02 4.3Product-contact welds finished as specified by the customer in clause 4.3Tank internal welds ground as specified. Orbital pipe welds left as welded and inspectedClarificationWeld procedure WP-EX-07; weld inspection planClause 4.3 does not say whether as-welded orbital welds are accepted. Ask.
6DrainabilityHDS-EX-02 5.1Equipment to drain by gravity, with slopes as specified by the customerTank bottom and pipework sloped as specified. The pump casing empties through a casing drain valve, not by gravityDeviationP&ID PID-EX-6410-01 Rev A; general arrangement GA-EX-6410Deviation list item 2. A casing drain valve is included.
7Dead legsHDS-EX-02 5.3Dead legs limited as specified by the customer in clause 5.3Instrument tees and branch valves chosen to the customer's limit. The sample point on the outlet line is longerDeviationPID-EX-6410-01 Rev A, line 4Deviation list item 3. A flush-mounted sample valve is offered as an option.
8Seals and elastomersHDS-EX-02 6.1Product-contact elastomers of the materials named, each with a food contact declaration for the regulations the customer listsGasket, valve seat and pump seal elastomers as named, with declarations for the regulations listedCompliesDeclarations DoC-EX-11 to DoC-EX-14
9Fasteners and threads in the product zoneHDS-EX-02 6.4No exposed threads or fasteners in the product zone unless the clause allows itNone in the product zone. Agitator blades are welded to the hubCompliesAgitator drawing AG-EX-6410 Rev A
10Cleanability and CIP provisionsHDS-EX-02 7.1Cleanable in place with the customer's CIP programme; spray device coverage proven by the test the customer namesSpray device fitted; coverage test offered at the factory acceptance testClarificationTank datasheet DS-EX-T-01; FAT planThe enquiry gives no CIP supply flow or pressure at the skid inlet. Ask for both before the spray device is sized.
11LubricantsHDS-EX-02 8.1Lubricants with possible incidental product contact to carry the registration the customer specifiesAgitator gearbox lubricant as specified; all lubricants listed in the manualCompliesLubricant list LL-EX-6410
12DocumentationHDS-EX-02 9.1Hygienic design documentation pack as listed in clause 9.1, including a hygienic design certificate for the pump under the scheme the customer namesMaterial certificates, surface finish records, weld log, elastomer declarations and lubricant list. The pump model offered is not certified under the scheme namedDeviationPump quotation PQ-EX-118Deviation list item 4. A certified pump model is a priced alternative.

The requirement cells say "as specified by the customer" wherever the customer's document would give a figure. No roughness value, slope, dead-leg limit or certificate type in the example is presented as a requirement of EHEDG, 3-A or any other guideline or standard; those documents and your contract hold the figures. Check the governing standard or contract. Every example value is invented: the project, customer, bidders, purchase order, prices and every document, certificate, serial and report number do not exist. Standards are named but not quoted.

Status values

StatusUse it when
CompliesWhat you offer meets the customer's clause as written, and a document shows it.
ClarificationThe clause is unclear, leaves something out, or your offer meets it by a different route. Ask the question in writing.
DeviationWhat you offer does not meet the clause as written. Say what you offer instead and carry the row to your deviation list.
Not applicableThe clause does not apply to the equipment offered, for example a clause on product-zone bearings where there are none. Say why.

Columns and what to write

ColumnWhat to write
ItemRunning number.
Requirement areaThe subject of the row, such as product-contact materials, surface finish, drainability or seals.
Customer clauseThe clause of the customer's hygienic design specification. If the customer has no clause on the subject, write None and treat the row as a question to ask.
What the customer specifiesThe requirement in the customer's own words, including any figure it gives. Do not fill in a figure from memory or from a guideline the customer did not name.
What is offeredWhat your equipment has, in the same terms, for every part of the scope including bought-in items.
StatusComplies, Clarification, Deviation or Not applicable (drop-down). Deviation rows turn red; Clarification rows amber.
Evidence documentThe drawing, materials list, certificate, declaration or procedure that supports the row, with its number and revision.
RemarkThe question to ask, the alternative you offer, or the deviation list item.

How to fill in the checklist

  1. Fill in the header block: the customer's hygienic design specification with its revision, and the guidelines and standards it names with their editions.
  2. Read the customer's specification from start to finish and write the clause number against each requirement area. Add rows for anything it covers that the template does not.
  3. In What the customer specifies, copy the customer's wording, including any figure. Leave figures out if the customer gives none; do not borrow one from a guideline the customer did not name.
  4. In What is offered, describe your equipment in the same terms. Check bought-in items one by one: pumps, valves, instruments and seals are where the gaps usually are.
  5. Set the status. Deviation rows turn red and Clarification rows amber.
  6. Name the evidence document for every Complies row. A row with no evidence is not ready to send.
  7. Carry each Deviation to your deviation list and each Clarification to your clarification list, and put the item number in the Remark column.
  8. Have the design engineer check the list before the offer goes out, and keep it with the offer file.

Reading the customer's specification against your own documents

Hygienic design clauses are scattered. Some sit in the hygienic design specification, others in the user requirements, the datasheets or a cleaning standard attached at the back. In OdysseyGPT's Tender & Quotation module, Document Review and Customer Specification Review (beta) read the customer's package and your datasheets, list each requirement and show what your documents say against it, quoting both pages. Deviation Register (beta) keeps the deviations and the customer's answers in one place. An engineer sets every status. Tools marked beta are open on request, and we onboard each team ourselves.

See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender

Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.

Book a call

New templates by email (optional)

Your download does not depend on this.

We use your email only for this. See our privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

What is hygienic design?

Designing equipment so that it can be cleaned reliably and does not hold product residue or micro-organisms: suitable materials, smooth and accessible surfaces, no crevices, and complete drainage.

What do hygienic design requirements usually cover?

Materials in contact with product, surface and weld finish, drainability, dead legs, seals and their food contact declarations, fasteners in the product zone, cleaning provisions, lubricants, and the documents that prove each of these. The customer's specification decides the detail.

Why are there no roughness or dead-leg figures in the template?

Because the binding figure is the one in your customer's specification, and customers differ. Guidelines are also revised from time to time. The template gives you a place to copy the customer's figure and set yours beside it.

Is this an EHEDG or 3-A checklist?

No. It is a layout for answering a customer's own specification. It does not reproduce EHEDG or 3-A content, and filling it in does not show conformity with either. For that, work from the documents themselves and the rules of the certification scheme.

Who should fill in a hygienic design checklist?

The proposal engineer starts it and a design engineer checks it, because several rows depend on drawing details such as slopes and branch lengths. Suppliers of bought-in parts answer for their own items.

References

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International

Creative Commons

Visit source

Related Pages