How do aerospace and defence suppliers review an order?
A build-to-print supplier does not write a technical offer against a tender specification. It receives a purchase order for a part number at a drawing revision, and the purchase order points to everything else. The work at contract review is to find every document the order calls up, confirm the revision of each, and decide whether the shop can meet it.
| Document | What it usually carries | What goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase order lines and notes | Part number, drawing revision, quantity, delivery dates and a list of quality clause codes | The order names a newer drawing revision than the one quoted |
| Quality clauses | Short coded requirements held on the customer's supplier portal, such as first article inspection, source inspection, certificate content or record retention | A code is accepted without anyone opening its text, or the clause has been revised since the last order |
| Supplier quality requirements manual | General rules for every order: quality system certification, control of sub-tier suppliers, non-conformance reporting, change notification | The manual is treated as boilerplate and read once, years ago |
| Drawing notes and parts list | Material and process specifications, marking, and any approved-source restrictions | A note calls up a process specification the shop's usual processor is not approved for |
| Material and process specifications | The detailed requirement for the stock, heat treatment, plating, coating, welding or non-destructive testing | The revision in force at order date differs from the one the route card was written to |
| Terms and conditions | Government flow-down clauses, export control statements and audit rights | A material sourcing clause is noticed only when the certificate is being written |
Most shops record this on a contract review form. A careful review ends with three lists: requirements the shop meets as it stands, requirements that must be passed to a sub-tier supplier, and points it cannot meet and must raise with the buyer before accepting the order.
- Collect the purchase order, each quality clause by code and revision, the supplier quality manual and the terms and conditions.
- Confirm the drawing, parts list and specification revisions against the order, and note any change since the quotation.
- List each obligation once, with the document and paragraph it comes from.
- Mark who must act on it: your own planning, inspection, purchasing, or a named sub-tier supplier.
- Write the sub-tier purchase orders so that each clause the customer says must be flowed down appears in them.
- Send exceptions to the buyer in writing and hold acceptance until they are answered.
Flow-down is your obligation, not the processor's
Customers commonly require a supplier to pass applicable requirements down to its own suppliers, including the customer's rights of access and any restriction to approved sources. If your order to a heat treater or plater leaves a clause out, the gap is found at the customer's audit or at receiving inspection, and it is found against you.
Which standards and rules come up?
The same handful of standards and regulations appear in most aerospace and defence purchase orders. The table names them and says what each is for. It is our own summary at title level. Read the revision your contract names, and take regulatory questions to a qualified adviser.
| Name | What it is | Where an order usually pins it down |
|---|---|---|
| AS9100 | The quality management system standard for aviation, space and defence organisations. It builds on ISO 9001 | Whether third-party certification is required, for which site, and whether sub-tier suppliers need it too |
| AS9102 | The first article inspection requirement: what is verified on a representative part from the first production run and how it is recorded | Which parts need a first article inspection, who approves the report and when it must be repeated |
| Nadcap | An industry-managed accreditation programme for special processes such as heat treating, non-destructive testing, welding and chemical processing | Which processes must be done by an accredited processor, and whether the customer's own approval is needed as well |
| DFARS specialty metals | A US defence acquisition clause that restricts where certain steels, nickel and cobalt alloys, titanium and zirconium may be melted or produced | Whether the clause is in the order, and what the material certificate or certificate of conformance must state |
| AS5553 and AS6174 | SAE standards on counterfeit parts. AS5553 covers electrical, electronic and electromechanical parts. AS6174 covers materiel in general | Purchasing from the original maker or an authorised source, and the traceability records to keep |
| ITAR and EAR | US export control regulations. ITAR covers defence articles and related technical data. EAR covers commercial and dual-use items | A statement on the drawing or order that the data is export controlled, and who may receive it |
This page does not explain how to comply with export control law or with any DFARS clause. It names them so a contract reviewer knows to look for them. For a quality system specification from another sector, compare API Q1.
What goes in the contract review exceptions list?
A build-to-print supplier cannot deviate from the drawing on its own authority. What it can do is tell the buyer, before acceptance, which requirements of the order it cannot meet or needs clarified. Some companies call this an exceptions list. In other sectors the same record is a technical deviation list. After acceptance, a departure goes through the customer's own request process for a deviation or concession.
| Area | What to check before you accept the order |
|---|---|
| Revisions | Drawing, parts list and specification revisions on the order against those quoted, and whether stock or work in progress is to the older revision |
| Quality clauses added since the quotation | Clause codes on the order that were not on the request for quotation, especially source inspection, first article and data submission clauses |
| Approved sources | Whether each special process must go to a processor on the customer's approved list, and whether your usual processor is on it for that specification |
| First article inspection | Whether a full or partial inspection is needed, whether an earlier report can be used, and whether the customer must approve the report before shipment |
| Material sourcing | Country of melt restrictions, the certificate statements asked for, and whether stock on the shelf can meet them |
| Certificate content | The statements the certificate of conformance must carry, who signs it and whether the customer's format is mandatory |
| Records and access | The retention period, and rights of entry for the customer, its customer and regulators at your site and at sub-tier suppliers |
| Change and non-conformance | Which changes need notice or approval first, and how fast a non-conformance found after delivery must be reported |
Keep the list short and exact. Each line needs the document, the paragraph, what you can do instead and what you want the buyer to confirm. A general statement that the order is accepted subject to your quotation does not protect you against a clause you did not name.
Which documents are delivered with the parts?
The paperwork that ships with the parts, or is uploaded to the customer's portal before they ship, is often called a data package. For a finished deliverable it may be called an end item data package. The order and its quality clauses set the contents. These are the usual ones.
| Document | What the customer looks for |
|---|---|
| First article inspection report | The part number and revision ordered, every design characteristic accounted for with a result, and the materials, special processes and functional tests listed with their evidence |
| Certificate of conformance | Purchase order and line, part number, revision, quantity, serial or lot numbers, the statements the quality clauses require, and an authorised signature |
| Material certificates | The specification and revision, the heat or lot number, results that meet the specification, and an unbroken link from the mill to the part. See heat number traceability |
| Special process certificates | The processor's name and site, the process specification and revision, the parts and quantity covered, the date, and a statement of conformance |
| Test and inspection reports | Functional, pressure or electrical test results, non-destructive testing reports and dimensional records where the order asks for them |
| Sub-tier certificates of conformance | A certificate from each sub-tier supplier whose work is in the part, tied to your purchase order to them |
| Deviation or concession approvals | The customer's signed approval for any accepted departure, referenced on the certificate of conformance |
| Index or packing list | A list of what is in the package, so receiving inspection can see at a glance that nothing is missing |
A checklist for the first document is on the first article inspection report checklist template page. For the certificate, see the certificate of conformance template. The guide on how to review a material test report covers the material certificates.
How does OdysseyGPT help?
OdysseyGPT is document review software. You upload the customer's documents and your own, and it reports where they differ, quoting the passage on each side. Document Review takes the customer's quality clauses or supplier quality manual as the base and checks your contract review record, quality plan or sub-tier purchase order against it, forward and in reverse. The other tools each read a narrower set of documents.
| Your document | Tool | What it reports |
|---|---|---|
| Supplier quality requirements manual, quality clause texts and terms | Customer Specification Review (beta) | A requirements register: one line per obligation, with the paragraph it comes from and its type |
| Customer's quality clauses and your purchase order to a sub-tier supplier | Document Review | Each customer requirement with a status and a quote from your order, so a clause that was not flowed down shows as not addressed |
| Your quotation and the purchase order received | Quotation-to-PO Review (beta) | New obligations, changed revisions and exceptions the order does not carry, each with a quote |
| Exceptions raised and the buyer's replies | Deviation Register (beta) | One running record of each exception, its status and the buyer's decision |
| Material certificates and the purchase requirements | Material Certificate Review (beta) | Grade, heat number, chemistry and mechanical results checked against the requirement, with the value quoted from the certificate |
| Parts list, heat or lot records and material certificates | Material Traceability Check (beta) | Heat numbers with no certificate, certificates that cover no part and conflicting grades |
| Test or inspection reports and calibration certificates | Calibration Validity Check (beta) | Each instrument named in a report matched to a certificate that was valid on the date of use |
| The customer's data package requirements and your document folder | MRB Readiness Check (beta) | Each required document shown as present, missing, awaiting approval or at the wrong revision |
| Approved records and the customer's package index | MRB Compiler (beta) | The records mapped to the index, with entries that have no document listed |
The record book tools were written around a manufacturing record book. An end item data package is the same kind of thing: an index set by the customer and a folder of evidence to check against it. The tools are grouped by stage under order, manufacturing and handover.
What does a result look like?
This table is an invented example. The customer, the bracket, the clause codes, the certificate numbers and the company names are made up to show how findings are laid out. Nothing in it comes from a real order, a real supplier or a standard. The rows are of the kind produced by Quotation-to-PO Review, Document Review, Material Certificate Review and MRB Readiness Check.
| ID | Finding | Why it was raised | Category | Severity | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F-01 | Quality clause Q-14 is not in the purchase order to the anodiser | Q-14 states "Supplier shall flow this clause to all sub-tier sources performing special processes." Sub-tier order SP-3391 lists clauses Q-02 and Q-07 only. | Flow-down | Critical | High |
| F-02 | Material certificate does not state the country of melt | Clause Q-21 states "Certificates for titanium shall state the country in which the material was melted." Certificate MC-88014, heat T4471, gives the mill's address and no melt statement. | Missing statement | High | High |
| F-03 | Anodising certificate is from a processor not on the approved list supplied | Clause Q-09 limits special processes to sources on approved processor list APL rev 12. Certificate AN-2207 names Northgate Finishing. That name does not appear on the list uploaded. | Approved source | Critical | Medium |
| F-04 | Purchase order calls up drawing revision D; the quotation was to revision C | Purchase order line 1 states "BRK-5520 Rev D". Quotation Q-1182 states "BRK-5520 Rev C". | Revision change | High | High |
| F-05 | First article inspection report is listed as required and is not in the folder | Clause Q-05 requires a first article inspection report with the first shipment. No document in the folder matches that index entry. | Completeness | Critical | High |
| F-06 | Certificate of conformance omits the concession number | Clause Q-03 states "Approved concessions shall be referenced on the certificate." Concession CN-0412 is in the folder. Certificate CC-7730 does not mention it. | Certificate content | Medium | Medium |
| F-07 | New obligation: record retention of 15 years | Purchase order terms, section 9, state 15 years. The quotation referred to the supplier's standard period of 10 years. | New obligation | Medium | High |
A quality engineer opens the quotes behind each row and confirms it, changes it or dismisses it. F-03 is a good example of why. The software can say that a name is not on the list it was given. Only a person can say whether the list was current, or whether the processor trades under another name.
Where OdysseyGPT falls short
- Export-controlled technical data needs your customer's and your own decision about where it may be processed and who may see it. OdysseyGPT is hosted in the United States. This page makes no claim of ITAR compliance, and you should not upload controlled data until that decision has been made.
- It makes no claim of CMMC or AS9100 certification or compliance, and it is not a quality management system. It does not hold your procedures, training records, audits or corrective actions.
- It does not read engineering drawings or 3D models. A requirement that exists only as a drawing note, a dimension or a model annotation is not checked unless you supply it as text.
- It is not first article inspection software. It does not balloon a drawing, measure a part, fill in first article forms or connect to a measuring machine.
- It does not confirm that a processor holds an accreditation or a customer approval. It can show what a certificate states and what a list you upload contains. Checking the live status is your job.
- It gives no legal or regulatory opinion. Whether material meets a DFARS clause, or whether an item is export controlled, is a question for your compliance function.
- It can miss a requirement or pair it with the wrong passage, most often where clause codes are listed without their text. The quotes are there so a person can catch this.
- Tools carrying a beta marker on this page are available on request, and we set each team up ourselves.
Try it on your own documents
Free sample: a quotation-vs-PO check
Send your quotation and the customer's purchase order. Get a list of what changed between them.
