How do water and wastewater equipment makers answer a bid?
A municipal treatment plant project is normally designed by a consulting engineer and built by a general contractor. The engineer writes a project manual: general and procedural sections at the front, then one technical section for each kind of equipment. The equipment maker quotes to the contractors who are bidding, often through a local representative, and usually has no contract with the owner at all.
In North America the manual follows the MasterFormat numbering published by the Construction Specifications Institute, which has a division for water and wastewater equipment and others for process piping and process equipment. Most equipment sections are written in three parts: general, products and execution. Requirements for the maker sit in all three.
| Part of the package | What it holds | What the maker has to do with it |
|---|---|---|
| The equipment section, Part 1 | Scope, referenced standards, the submittals wanted, quality assurance, experience clauses, warranty and spare parts | List every submittal item and every qualification clause. These are the ones a product datasheet does not answer |
| The equipment section, Part 2 | Named manufacturers, performance and design conditions, materials, coatings, motors, controls and factory tests | Compare line by line with the standard product and note each difference |
| The equipment section, Part 3 | Installation, the manufacturer's field services, field tests, training and start-up | Price the days on site and the trips, and check what the field test must prove |
| The equipment schedule | Tag numbers, quantities, duty points, sizes and motor ratings for each unit, on a drawing sheet or at the back of the section | Check each tag against the section text. The schedule and the text do not always agree |
| The general submittal section | How submittals are numbered, packaged, certified, reviewed and resubmitted | Build the package to it. The rules apply to every section in the manual |
| Addenda | Changes and answers to bidders' questions issued before bid day | Re-read the section after each one. An addendum can change a duty point or add a named manufacturer |
Many sections name one or more manufacturers and add "or equal" or "or approved equal". The clause decides how an unnamed maker gets in. Some specifications want a substitution request approved before bid day, with a deadline. Others leave it to the submittal after award, which puts the risk on the contractor who carried the price. Read the substitution article in the front-end sections as well as the equipment section, because the two are meant to be read together.
The maker's answer at bid is short: a scope letter that names the section and the addenda received, states what is included and excluded, and lists the exceptions. The full answer comes after award, in the submittal.
Which standards and approvals come up in water equipment specifications?
A water equipment section usually cites a product standard, a drinking water contact standard where the equipment touches potable water, and a funding or procurement clause. The table gives the ones that appear most often, at name level. It is our own summary. Use the edition and the wording your contract gives.
| Reference | What it is | What the section usually asks the maker for |
|---|---|---|
| AWWA standards, pipe and accessories group | American Water Works Association standards for pipe, linings and coatings, valves, hydrants, actuators and slide gates, numbered with a C. C504 covers rubber-seated butterfly valves and C509 and C515 cover resilient-seated gate valves | A statement that the product conforms to the named standard, the purchaser options chosen, and the test records the standard calls for |
| AWWA pump and plant equipment groups | E102 and E103 cover submersible vertical turbine pumps and horizontal centrifugal and vertical line shaft pumps. The F group covers items such as ultraviolet disinfection and ozone systems | Confirmation of conformance and the factory test evidence set by the section |
| AWWA treatment group | Standards numbered with a B for filter media, membrane systems and treatment chemicals | Named for media and membrane packages. Check which parts apply to supplied equipment and which to the plant operator |
| NSF/ANSI/CAN 61 | A health effects standard for products and materials that touch drinking water. A product is tested and listed by an accredited certification body | The listing for the exact model, size and material offered, from the certifier's directory |
| NSF/ANSI/CAN 372 | A standard for evaluating the lead content of drinking water products | Evidence of compliance for wetted parts where the lead free rules apply |
| Regulation 31 and WRAS approval (United Kingdom) | Regulation 31 governs products that water companies use in public supply in England, with matching rules in the other nations. WRAS approval is a certification scheme for fittings installed in premises under the Water Fittings Regulations | Which regime the buyer means. They cover different parts of the system and are not interchangeable |
| Domestic preference clauses (United States) | The Build America, Buy America Act covers iron, steel, manufactured products and construction materials on federally funded infrastructure. The older American Iron and Steel requirement covers iron and steel products on State Revolving Fund projects | A signed statement of where the product is made, in the form the funding agency or the contractor asks for |
A domestic preference clause is a bid decision
Whether a product meets a domestic preference clause depends on where it and its components are made and on the agency's current rules and waivers. Treat the clause as a question for your own compliance or legal function before bid day. If the answer is no or not yet known, say so in the scope letter.
AWWA does not test, certify or approve products, so "AWWA approved" in a specification has no formal meaning. What the engineer can ask for is the maker's statement of conformance and the records the standard requires. An NSF/ANSI/CAN 61 listing is different: it is issued by a third party and can be looked up.
What goes in the list of exceptions?
The list of exceptions names each paragraph of the section the offer does not meet as written, says what is offered in its place and gives the reason. Engineers and contractors in this sector also call it a list of deviations or clarifications. The same areas come up on most water and wastewater equipment offers.
| Area | What to check before the scope letter goes out |
|---|---|
| Materials of construction | Wetted part materials, shaft and fastener grades and elastomers against your standard build, especially where the section copies another maker's material list |
| Coatings and linings | The paint system, surface preparation, film thickness and holiday testing the section names, against your shop standard, and whether the lining must be listed for drinking water contact |
| Drinking water contact evidence | Whether a listing exists for the exact model, size and material offered. A listing for a different size range or lining is not evidence for this one |
| Performance and duty points | Each tag in the equipment schedule against your selection, including conditions stated only in a note |
| Motors, drives and controls | Enclosure, efficiency class, voltage, variable speed drive compatibility, named makes for control components and the panel standard |
| Experience and reference clauses | Required years in production, numbers of similar installations and reference lists. These are yes or no questions and cannot be engineered around |
| Factory tests and witnessing | Which tests are on every unit, which are witnessed, and who pays for the witness to attend |
| Field services | Days and trips for installation checks, start-up, field testing and operator training, compared with what the price allows |
| Warranty and spares | Warranty period and start date, extended or special warranties, and the spare parts and special tools listed |
| Domestic preference | Whether the product as built for this order meets the clause, and what statement can be signed |
Declare at bid, not in the submittal
Many general submittal sections require the contractor to flag every variation from the contract documents when the submittal is made, and some state that review does not approve a variation that was not flagged. An exception left out of the scope letter tends to surface at exactly that point, after the price is fixed.
For the format of a deviation line, see the technical deviation list guide. A clause-by-clause table that covers the whole section is a compliance matrix.
How does the submittal process work after award?
After award the contractor issues a purchase order and asks for the submittal. A construction submittal is the package that shows the engineer what will be supplied before it is made or shipped. The maker prepares it, the contractor reviews and stamps it, and the engineer reviews it against the section.
| Item | What it is | What the reviewer checks |
|---|---|---|
| Product data | Catalogue pages, datasheets, performance curves, materials lists and motor data, marked to show the model and options offered | That the marked-up data matches each paragraph of Part 2 and each tag in the schedule |
| Shop drawings | Drawings prepared for this project: dimensions, weights, anchor locations, connections, wiring and control diagrams. See shop drawing submittal | Fit with the structure, piping and electrical design |
| Design data and calculations | Selections, sizing and, where the section asks, anchorage or seismic calculations | That the basis matches the stated design conditions |
| Certificates | Statements of conformance to named standards, drinking water contact listings, domestic preference statements and welder or coating applicator qualifications | That each certificate names this project and this product |
| Test reports | Factory test procedures before the test, and results afterwards | That the test and its acceptance basis are the ones the section sets |
| Manufacturer's instructions | Storage, handling and installation instructions | That they exist before the equipment arrives on site |
| Operation and maintenance data | The O&M manual, often in a draft before shipment and a final after start-up | Content and format against the O&M article, which is often in a separate section |
| Closeout items | Warranty certificates, field service reports, training records and spare parts lists | That everything the section promised has been handed over |
The engineer returns each submittal with a review action. The wording is set by the contract and varies. Common actions are approved, approved as noted, revise and resubmit, and rejected, and some engineers avoid the word "approved" and write "no exceptions taken" or "make corrections noted". The public US federal guide specification for submittal procedures uses approved as submitted, approved as noted, and disapproved with a resubmission. An approved as noted return still carries obligations: each note has to be answered or built in.
The contractor tracks every item on a submittal log, also called a submittal register. A maker with more than one section on a project needs its own copy, with each resubmission and each review comment against it. A free submittal log template is available. The maker's side of the same job, where the order carries a document list, is the vendor data requirements list.
Which factory tests and certificates are asked for?
Test and certificate requirements sit in three places: the named standard, the equipment section and the general quality sections. The section can add to the standard, and it often does.
| Record | Typical source of the requirement | What to confirm at bid |
|---|---|---|
| Pump performance test report | The pump section, which names a test standard and an acceptance grade | Whether the test is on every pump or one per size, certified or witnessed, and with the job motor or a shop motor |
| Valve and gate test records | The AWWA standard named for the valve or gate type, plus any extra tests in the section | Which tests the section adds or makes witnessed, and whether actuators are tested mounted |
| Coating and lining records | The coating section or the coating standard named in the equipment section | Surface preparation, thickness and holiday test records, and who signs them |
| Material certificates | The section's materials article | Whether certified mill test reports are required for castings, shafts or pressure parts, or a certificate of conformance is enough |
| Drinking water contact listing | The section's reference to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61 or to a national approval | That the listing covers the model, size, material and lining on this order |
| Certificate of conformance | The submittal article | The exact wording wanted. See certificate of conformance |
| Calibration evidence | The test article or the general quality section | Whether certificates for test instruments must be included with the test report |
| Factory acceptance test for packaged systems | Sections for skid-mounted, membrane, dosing and control panel packages | The procedure approval step, the notice period and what counts as a pass. See FAT vs SAT |
Field tests are separate. Part 3 of the section normally sets a functional test and sometimes a performance test on site, with the manufacturer's representative present and a signed certificate of proper installation. Those days belong in the price and in the scope letter.
How does OdysseyGPT help?
OdysseyGPT reads the documents you upload and checks them against the written requirements. Every finding shows the passage it rests on in both documents. Document Review takes one document as the base, such as the equipment section with its addenda, and checks the documents you select against it: your product data, scope letter, certificates and draft O&M manual. It works in both directions, so it also lists commitments in your documents that the section does not ask for. The other tools each take a narrower set of documents.
| Your document | Tool | What it reports |
|---|---|---|
| The equipment section, the general submittal section and your offer or submittal package | Document Review | A status and a pair of quotes for each paragraph of the section, and an editable matrix with a list of exceptions and clarifications |
| The project manual sections and addenda that apply to your equipment | Customer Specification Review (beta) | A requirements register: one line each for technical, quality, test and document obligations, with the paragraph it came from |
| The engineer's equipment schedule or datasheet as a spreadsheet, and your filled datasheet | Datasheet Comparison (beta) | Matched fields and each material difference in value, with the cell it came from |
| Scope letter, clarification replies and returned review comments | Deviation Register (beta) | One running record of each exception, declared or not, through to the engineer's decision |
| The contractor's list of required documents for your order | VDRL/MDR Tracker (beta) | A register of each document with its due date, revision and review status, and overdue resubmissions flagged |
| Mill test reports for castings, shafts and pressure parts | Material Certificate Review (beta) | Each certificate checked against the purchase requirements and the material specification |
| Your inspection and test plan and the section's quality and test articles | ITP Validator (beta) | Tests the section asks for that the plan leaves out, and witness points that do not match |
| Factory test reports and instrument calibration certificates | Calibration Validity Check (beta) | Each instrument named in a report matched to a certificate and checked for validity on the test date |
| Factory acceptance test procedure, ITP, calibration evidence and open items for a packaged system | FAT Readiness Check (beta) | A readiness verdict, with blockers listed apart from review items |
| The closeout folder and the contract's required index | MRB Readiness Check (beta) and MRB Compiler (beta) | Documents that are missing, unapproved or at the wrong revision, and a manifest in index order |
The tools are grouped by stage: tender, order, inspection and handover. Makers of rotating equipment and valves for other industries have their own pages: pump manufacturers and valve manufacturers.
What does a result look like?
This table is an invented example. The project, the section and paragraph numbers, the pump, the maker's documents and every figure are made up to show how a result is laid out. None of it comes from a real specification, a real manufacturer or a standard.
| Specification requirement (quoted) | Maker's document (quoted) | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Each pump shall deliver 2,100 gpm at 185 ft total dynamic head." (Section 43 21 39, 2.02.A) | "Rated condition: 2,100 USgpm at 185 ft TDH." (Pump datasheet PD-114, line 6) | Complies | Same duty point in both documents. |
| "All materials in contact with potable water shall be certified to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61." (2.03.A) | "Bowl assembly listed to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61. Column pipe lining: shop epoxy, two coats." (Product data, p. 4) | Clarification | The bowl assembly is stated as listed. Nothing is said about a listing for the column pipe lining. |
| "Line shaft shall be Type 416 stainless steel." (2.04.C) | "Line shaft: AISI 1045 carbon steel with stainless steel sleeves at bearings." (Bill of materials, item 12) | Deviates | A different shaft material is offered. It is not in the scope letter's list of exceptions. |
| "Each pump shall be factory performance tested with the job motor. The test shall be witnessed by the Engineer." (2.07.B) | "Certified non-witnessed performance test with calibrated shop motor." (Scope letter, item 7) | Deviates | A shop motor and a non-witnessed test are offered in place of the section's test. |
| "Furnish an anchor bolt design calculation sealed by a professional engineer registered in the State." (1.04.D) | No matching statement found in the documents supplied. | Not addressed | Not in the submittal contents list. Add it or declare it. |
| "Manufacturer shall have not less than ten installations of similar size in municipal service for five years." (1.05.A) | "Reference list: eight municipal installations, 2014 to 2023." (Reference list, p. 1) | Clarification | Eight are listed and the list does not say which are of similar size. |
| "Furnish the services of a factory representative for not less than three days in two trips for start-up and training." (3.04.A) | "Includes one trip, two days on site, for start-up assistance." (Scope letter, item 11) | Deviates | Fewer days and trips are offered, and training is not mentioned. |
| "Provide a certification that iron and steel products comply with the domestic preference requirements of the funding agency." (1.04.G) | "Castings poured and machined at our works. Certification letter available on request." (Scope letter, item 14) | Clarification | A letter is offered on request and is not in the package. |
A bid engineer or submittals coordinator opens the two quotes on each row and confirms or changes the status. Rows left as deviates go to the list of exceptions. Rows left as clarification become questions to the contractor or additions to the package before it is sent.
Where OdysseyGPT falls short
- It is not submittal workflow software. It does not number, route, stamp or distribute submittals, and it does not replace the contractor's or the engineer's project platform.
- It does not read drawings. Layouts, sections, piping and instrumentation diagrams and an equipment schedule that exists only as a drawing sheet are not checked. A schedule supplied as a spreadsheet or as text in the section can be.
- It does no hydraulic or process design. It does not select a pump, check a system curve, size a clarifier or filter, or tell you whether a duty point can be met.
- It certifies nothing. It cannot confirm that a product is listed to NSF/ANSI/CAN 61 or approved under a national regime. It can show what your certificate says next to what the section asks for.
- It does not decide whether a product meets a domestic preference clause. That turns on where things are made and on the agency's rules.
- It holds no standards. A requirement that sits only inside an AWWA standard is checked only if you upload the edition and the text is readable.
- It can match a paragraph to the wrong passage or miss one, most often where several tags share one section. The quotes are there so a person can catch it.
- Tools that carry a beta marker on this page are available on request, and we set each team up ourselves.
Talk through your tender review
See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender
Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.
