How do marine equipment makers answer a shipyard enquiry?
A shipyard buys equipment for a hull number, not for a site. The enquiry for a pump set, a windlass, a switchboard or a set of fire dampers arrives as a bundle, and each part of the bundle has a different author.
| Document | Who wrote it | What it decides for the maker |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase order specification, sometimes called the POS or technical purchase specification | The yard's design or purchasing department | Scope of supply, duty, materials, interfaces, tests, drawings and delivery for this item |
| Extract of the building specification | The owner and the yard, as part of the shipbuilding contract | The owner's wishes that go beyond the rules: preferred makes, materials, spares, redundancy, paint and nameplates |
| Class and notation | The owner chooses the classification society. The notation is written in the building specification | Which society's rules apply, and which extra notations add requirements to your equipment |
| Flag state | The owner chooses the ship's register | Which statutory approvals apply, for example the wheel mark on a ship under an EU flag |
| Makers' list | Agreed between the owner and the yard | Whether your company is a named maker for the item, or has to be proposed and accepted |
| Yard standards and general conditions | The yard | Drawing format, document numbering, vibration, noise, colour, packing and warranty terms |
The work is to read the whole bundle and state, item by item, what you offer. A typical order of work looks like this.
- Find the hull number, the classification society, the full class notation and the flag. If any is missing, ask before you quote.
- Check whether you are on the makers' list for the item. If not, find out how the yard wants an alternative maker proposed.
- List every requirement in the purchase order specification and in the building specification extract, with its clause.
- For each item, decide which approval route applies: an existing type approval, a design approval for this ship, a statutory approval, or none.
- Compare the requirements with your datasheet, standard scope, approvals held, test procedure and standard spares list.
- Mark each row complies, deviates, clarification or not addressed, and price what the standard offer leaves out, such as surveyor attendance and extra certificates.
The result is a compliance matrix for the yard and a technical deviation list that carries only the differences. Yards compare several makers quickly. A clear list of what is and is not approved saves a round of questions.
Which rules and standards come up in a shipyard enquiry?
Marine equipment sits under two layers. Classification rules belong to the society the owner chose. Statutory requirements come from international conventions and are applied by the flag state. The table lists what an enquiry usually names. It is our own summary at name level. Use the rules and the edition your contract names.
| Source | What it is | What to pin down in the enquiry |
|---|---|---|
| Classification society rules | Each society publishes its own rules for ships. DNV, the American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), Lloyd's Register, Bureau Veritas and ClassNK are among the twelve member societies of IACS | The society, the rule edition that applies to this hull and the full class notation |
| IACS unified requirements | Minimum technical requirements agreed by the IACS members and written into each society's own rules. The series are lettered, for example E for electrical and electronic installations, M for machinery installations, P for pipes and pressure vessels and W for materials and welding | The society's rules are what you are checked against. A member may set stricter requirements than the unified text |
| IACS unified interpretations | Agreed readings of IMO convention requirements, used when a flag state has given no instruction of its own | Whether the flag state has its own interpretation for your item |
| SOLAS and other IMO instruments | The Safety of Life at Sea convention, MARPOL for pollution prevention and COLREG for collision prevention, with the codes made under them | Which convention requirement makes your item subject to flag state approval |
| Marine Equipment Directive 2014/90/EU | EU law for equipment on ships under an EU flag where the conventions require flag state approval. Conforming equipment carries the wheel mark | Whether the ship flies an EU flag and whether your item is listed in the current implementing regulation |
| UK marine equipment regulations | The Merchant Shipping (Marine Equipment) Regulations 2025 for UK ships, with the technical lists in Merchant Shipping Notice MSN 1874 | Whether the ship is on the UK register. UK approval is given by a UK approved body and shown by the UK conformity mark |
| Product standards | ISO, IEC, EN and national standards for the item itself | The edition, and whether class rules or the yard's specification change anything in it |
Class approval and statutory approval are separate. On a ship under an EU flag, a fire damper or a navigation light needs the wheel mark, while the switchboard beside it needs the society's approval. A yard can also ask for both on one item. The page on class type approval explains the class side. The Marine Equipment Directive page explains the EU statutory side.
One society's approval does not stand in for another's
DNV's published answers for manufacturers say that a certificate from another classification society generally cannot replace a DNV certificate, and that tests witnessed by another society are not accepted in place of its own. Other societies have their own positions. Do not offer an approval from society A against an enquiry for a ship classed by society B without saying so in the deviation list.
What goes in the deviation list for marine equipment?
The deviation list tells the yard where the offer differs from the enquiry. For marine equipment the differences are less about duty points and more about approval and evidence. These are the areas to check before the offer goes out.
| Area | What to check before you sign the offer |
|---|---|
| Class approval status | Whether the model offered holds a type approval certificate from the society named, whether the certificate is in date, and whether the size, rating and options offered fall inside what the certificate covers |
| Certificate type | Whether the yard asks for a certificate issued by the society for each unit, or accepts the maker's own works certificate or test report. The rules set a minimum and the yard may ask for more |
| Statutory approval | Whether the flag makes the item subject to the wheel mark or the UK conformity mark, and whether you hold that approval for the model offered |
| Test witnessing | Which works tests the surveyor must attend, which the yard or owner also wants to attend, the notice period, and who pays for attendance |
| Drawings for approval | Which drawings go to the society, who submits them, the yard's or the maker's, and how many review rounds the delivery date allows |
| Materials | Which parts need material certificates of the type the society requires, and whether your sub-suppliers can provide them. See EN 10204 3.1 vs 3.2 |
| Spares and tools | The spares the class rules or the notation call for, compared with the spares the building specification asks for and your standard list |
| Owner's extras | Preferred makes of motors, bearings, seals or controls, material upgrades, and ambient or inclination conditions stated above your standard design basis |
| Documents and language | The drawing schedule, the number of copies, the format of manuals and the language of nameplates and instructions |
Say which approval route you priced
If the model has no type approval from the named society, the usual alternative is approval of the design for this ship, followed by survey of the unit. That takes time and fees. State the route, the cost and the effect on delivery in the offer. A yard that learns of it after award will treat it as your delay.
Which documents follow after award?
After the order the yard sends a drawing and document schedule. It is the marine version of a vendor data requirements list. The purchase order decides the list. These are the items a marine equipment maker should expect.
| Document | What the yard and the surveyor look for |
|---|---|
| Drawings submitted for class approval | The drawings and calculations the rules list for the item, at a stated revision, with the society's approval stamp or comments and the reply to each comment |
| Drawings for yard approval and working drawings | Outline, foundation, connection and wiring information the yard needs to build the ship around the item |
| Type approval certificate | The certificate for the model delivered, in date, with the conditions and limits printed on it |
| Product or unit certificate | Where the rules require it, a certificate issued by the society for the delivered unit after survey at the works, tied to the serial number |
| Statutory certificates | For an EU flag, the module certificates behind the wheel mark and the EU declaration of conformity. For the UK register, the UK equivalents |
| Material certificates | Certificates of the type the society requires for the listed parts, traceable to the parts by heat or cast number |
| Works test records | Pressure, running, load or functional test records by serial number, signed by those who witnessed them. See FAT vs SAT |
| Maker's declaration or certificate of conformance | The maker's own statement that the unit meets the order. See certificate of conformance |
| Spares and tools list | The items supplied, set against the class-required and owner-required lists |
| Final documentation | Instruction manuals, as-built drawings and certificates in the number of sets the order states: some for the yard, some for the ship and some for the owner's office |
A checklist for the certificate set is on the class certificate checklist template page. For the register itself, see the vendor document register template.
How does OdysseyGPT help?
OdysseyGPT reads the documents you upload and checks them against the yard's written requirements. Every finding shows the passage it rests on in both documents. Document Review takes the purchase order specification and building specification extract as the base, and your datasheet, standard scope, approvals list and offer text as the documents to check. It checks in both directions and exports an editable compliance matrix with a list of deviations and clarifications. The other tools each read a narrower set.
| Your document | Tool | What it reports |
|---|---|---|
| Yard specification, building specification extract and your offer documents | Document Review | A status and two quotes for each yard requirement, and statements in your offer that the enquiry does not answer |
| Purchase order specification and yard standards | Customer Specification Review (beta) | A register with one line per obligation: approvals, certificates, witnessed tests, drawings and spares, each with its clause |
| The yard's equipment datasheet and your filled copy | Datasheet Comparison (beta) | Matched fields and each material difference in value, with the place each figure was read from |
| Offer, yard comments and your replies | Deviation Register (beta) | A single record of each deviation from the offer through the clarification rounds to the yard's decision |
| The yard's drawing and document schedule | VDRL/MDR Tracker (beta) | A register of each submission with its due date, revision and status |
| Material certificates and the order's material requirements | Material Certificate Review (beta) | Grade, heat number, results and certificate type on each certificate, set against what the order asks for |
| Your inspection and test plan and the yard's test clauses | ITP Validator (beta) | Tests the yard asks for that the plan leaves out, and witness points that do not match |
| Works test records and instrument calibration certificates | Calibration Validity Check (beta) | Each instrument named in a test record matched to a certificate that was valid on the test date |
| Test procedure, approved drawing status and open comments before a witnessed test | FAT Readiness Check (beta) | Whether the documents the test depends on are in place before the surveyor and the yard travel |
| The final documentation folder and the yard's index | MRB Readiness Check (beta) and MRB Compiler (beta) | Documents that are missing, unapproved or at the wrong revision, and a manifest in the yard's index order |
The tools are grouped by stage: tender, order, inspection and handover. Makers of pumps, valves and electrical equipment who also sell to land-based buyers have their own pages.
What does a result look like?
This table is an invented example. The yard, the hull, the pump, the clause numbers, the maker's documents and every figure are made up to show how a result is laid out. Nothing in it comes from a real enquiry, a real maker, a class rule or a statutory text.
| Yard requirement (quoted) | Maker's document (quoted) | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Capacity 180 m3/h at 9 bar. Casing and impeller in nickel aluminium bronze." (POS-4410, 3.1) | "Duty: 180 m3/h at 9.0 bar. Casing: NiAl bronze. Impeller: NiAl bronze." (Datasheet DS-FP-180, p. 1) | Complies | Same duty and materials in both documents. |
| "Pumps shall be of a type approved by the Classification Society. A copy of the valid certificate shall be enclosed with the offer." (POS-4410, 2.2) | "Type approval: certificate TA-0932, valid to 14 March 2027, pump range FP 100 to FP 150." (Approvals list AL-07, line 6) | Clarification | The certificate range quoted stops below the size offered. An engineer should check the certificate itself. |
| "Each pump shall be delivered with a certificate issued by the Classification Society." (POS-4410, 6.1) | "Pumps are supplied with the manufacturer's works certificate." (Standard scope SS-12, p. 3) | Deviates | A maker's certificate is offered where the yard asks for one issued by the society. |
| "Hydrostatic and running tests shall be witnessed by the Surveyor and the Builder. Ten working days' notice is required." (POS-4410, 6.3) | "Witnessed testing is available at extra cost. Notice of test: 5 working days." (Quality plan QP-3, p. 4) | Deviates | Attendance is priced as an option and the notice period is shorter than asked. |
| "Material certificates for casing, impeller and shaft shall be of the type required by the Rules." (POS-4410, 6.4) | "Material certificates to EN 10204 type 3.1 for casing and impeller." (Standard scope SS-12, p. 3) | Clarification | The shaft is not mentioned, and the maker's text does not say the type matches the rules. |
| "Drawings listed in Annex B shall be submitted for approval within four weeks of order." (POS-4410, 7.1) | "Approval drawings: 6 weeks after receipt of order." (Offer letter, p. 2) | Deviates | The submission period offered is two weeks longer. |
| "Spare parts shall be as required by the Rules and, in addition, one mechanical seal per pump." (Building specification extract, 541.3) | "Standard spares: one set of bearings and one set of wear rings per pump type." (Spares list SP-FP, p. 1) | Deviates | No mechanical seal is listed. The class-required spares are not referred to. |
| "Motors shall be of a make on the Makers' List, item E-12." (POS-4410, 4.2) | No matching statement found in the documents supplied. | Not addressed | The motor make is not stated in the datasheet or the offer. |
A sales or project engineer opens both quotes on each row and confirms or changes the status. Rows left as deviates or clarification go into the deviation list and the questions to the yard. OdysseyGPT did not open the type approval certificate in a register. It read the line in the maker's approvals list.
Where OdysseyGPT falls short
- It does not replace plan approval or survey. The classification society approves drawings and its surveyor attends tests. OdysseyGPT has no part in either and issues no certificate.
- It does not read drawings. General arrangements, sectional drawings, piping diagrams and wiring diagrams are outside what it checks. A requirement that appears only on a drawing is missed.
- It does not look up approval registers. It cannot tell you whether a type approval certificate is still valid in a society's database or in the EU portal. It reads the certificate or list you upload.
- It holds no class rules, IACS resolutions or statutory texts. A requirement that sits only inside the rules is checked only if you upload that edition as readable text.
- It does not judge whether a certificate covers the model, size or option you offer. It shows what the certificate says and what the yard asks for. An engineer decides.
- It does no design work. It does not size a pump, rate a switchboard or calculate a windlass load.
- It can pair a requirement with the wrong line or miss one, most often where the specification repeats similar clauses for several items. The quotes are there so a person can catch this.
- Tools that carry a beta marker on this page are available on request, and we set each team up ourselves.
Talk through your tender review
See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender
Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.
