OdysseyGPT

Standards explainer

ASME NQA-1 explained: the nuclear quality assurance standard, its four parts and what to check in a purchaser's requirements

A plain-English overview of ASME NQA-1 for quality and project engineers at equipment makers who see it named in a nuclear purchase order, ending with a checklist for the purchaser's quality requirements.

By Ademola Afolabi, Founder, New Odyssey Ltd · Last reviewed:

The short answer

ASME NQA-1 is the American Society of Mechanical Engineers' standard of quality assurance requirements for nuclear facility applications. Part I sets eighteen requirements that mirror the eighteen criteria of 10 CFR 50 Appendix B. Part II adds requirements for specific kinds of work. Parts III and IV are guidance. The contract or licensing basis sets the edition.

Key Takeaways

  • NQA-1 says how a nuclear quality assurance programme must work. It is not a product or design code.
  • Part I holds eighteen requirements, numbered to match the eighteen criteria of 10 CFR 50 Appendix B.
  • Appendix B is the regulation. NQA-1 is a consensus standard the US regulator accepts, with conditions, as a way to meet it.
  • A purchase order names an edition. A supplier's programme written to another edition needs a gap review or an exception.

See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender. Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together. Book a call

What is ASME NQA-1?

NQA-1, Quality Assurance Requirements for Nuclear Facility Applications, is a standard published by ASME. It sets out what an organisation's quality assurance programme must control when its work affects a nuclear facility. ASME describes its scope as the structures, systems, components, activities and organisations that matter to the safe and reliable performance of a nuclear facility, over the whole life of the facility.

It is a programme standard. It does not say how thick a valve body must be or how a weld is examined. It says that design must be controlled, that purchase orders must carry the right requirements, that inspections must be planned and recorded, and that records must be kept. The technical rules come from the equipment specification and the code of construction, such as ASME Section III.

NQA-1 replaced the earlier N45.2 series of nuclear quality standards. A separate standard, NQA-2, was folded into it in the 1994 edition.

How is NQA-1 organised?

The four parts of NQA-1 in outline (own summary; read the edition your contract names)
PartWhat it holdsHow a purchase order uses it
Part IThe requirements for a quality assurance programme, arranged as Requirements 1 to 18Named in almost every order that invokes NQA-1. Some orders name only certain requirements for a limited scope of work.
Part IIFurther requirements for particular kinds of work, set out in subparts. Software is one of the subjects with its own subpart.Named subpart by subpart, where the work in the order matches
Part IIINonmandatory guidance on applying Parts I and IINot a requirement unless the order makes it one
Part IVNonmandatory guidance on using NQA-1, including comparisons with other quality requirementsUsed as background, for example when comparing NQA-1 with a regulation or another standard

Check which parts the order names. "NQA-1" alone is ambiguous. "NQA-1, Part I and Part II" with an edition is a clear requirement.

The eighteen requirements

Part I is built on eighteen requirement areas. Each has a number and a title, and each matches the criterion with the same number in 10 CFR 50 Appendix B. The table gives the titles, with a plain note on what each means for an equipment maker. The notes are ours, not the standard's wording.

NQA-1 Part I requirement titles, with our plain-language note for an equipment maker
No.TitleWhat it means on a supply order
1OrganizationWho is responsible for quality, and their freedom to stop work
2Quality Assurance ProgramThe written programme, its scope, and training and qualification of people
3Design ControlDesign inputs, checks, changes and verification, where you hold design responsibility
4Procurement Document ControlWhat your purchase orders to sub-suppliers must say
5Instructions, Procedures and DrawingsWork done to written, approved documents
6Document ControlIssue, revision and distribution of those documents
7Control of Purchased Items and ServicesEvaluating sub-suppliers and accepting what they deliver
8Identification and Control of ItemsMarking and traceability, so each part can be tied to its records
9Control of Special ProcessesWelding, heat treatment and NDE by qualified people to qualified procedures
10InspectionPlanned inspections, hold points and independent inspectors
11Test ControlTests run to written procedures with stated acceptance limits
12Control of Measuring and Test EquipmentCalibration, and what happens when an instrument is found out of tolerance
13Handling, Storage and ShippingCleanliness, preservation and packing
14Inspection, Test and Operating StatusShowing which items have passed which steps
15Control of Nonconforming ItemsIdentifying, segregating and dispositioning items that do not meet requirements
16Corrective ActionFinding the cause of significant problems and preventing a repeat
17Quality Assurance RecordsWhich records exist, how they are kept and for how long
18AuditsPlanned internal and supplier audits by people independent of the work

A purchaser's quality requirements often follow the same order. If you set your compliance matrix out under the same eighteen headings, the purchaser's reviewer can follow it without a cross-reference.

How does NQA-1 relate to 10 CFR 50 Appendix B?

Appendix B and NQA-1 compared (own summary of public sources)
Point10 CFR 50 Appendix BASME NQA-1
What it isA US federal regulationA consensus standard published by ASME
Who it bindsApplicants and licensees for US nuclear power plants and fuel reprocessing plantsWhoever a contract, a licence commitment or a code requires to follow it
Level of detailEighteen short criteria that state what must be controlledEighteen requirements with more detail on how, plus further parts
How a supplier meets itThrough the purchase order, which passes the criteria downBy writing and working to a programme that meets the named edition
Who checksThe licensee and its contractors, by audit and surveillance. The regulator inspects licensees and may inspect vendorsThe purchaser's auditors. ASME also runs an NQA-1 certification programme for providers of nuclear safety products and services

The link between the two is a regulatory guide. In Regulatory Guide 1.28 the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission says which NQA-1 editions it accepts as a way to meet Appendix B during design and construction, and on what conditions. Revision 6, issued in 2023, covers Parts I and II of the 2017, 2019 and 2022 editions, with exceptions and clarifications. Earlier revisions of the guide covered earlier editions.

So NQA-1 does not replace Appendix B. A US purchase order for a safety-related item often names both, and adds 10 CFR Part 21 on reporting defects.

Which edition applies?

ASME revises NQA-1 every few years. Editions in recent use include 2008 with its 2009 and 2011 addenda, 2012, 2015, 2017, 2019, 2022 and 2024. ASME's product page shows the edition now on sale.

The newest edition is not automatically the right one. A plant's licensing basis commits its owner to a particular edition, and the owner passes that edition down the supply chain. Two purchasers can therefore send the same supplier orders that name different editions. ASME's own NQA-1 certification lets an organisation either follow the current edition or hold its programme at a stated edition from 2008 onward.

  • Use the edition and addenda the purchase order names.
  • If your programme is written to another edition, compare the two and record the differences before you sign the order.
  • If the order names no edition, ask. Do not assume the latest.
  • Pass the same edition to your sub-suppliers, or state in your order which edition you accept from them.

What to check in a purchaser's NQA-1 quality requirements

Checklist for the quality requirements in a nuclear enquiry (not a substitute for reading the standard)
CheckWhy it matters
The edition and addenda of NQA-1, and which parts and subparts are namedYour programme and your last audit are tied to an edition
Whether 10 CFR 50 Appendix B and 10 CFR Part 21 are also invokedPart 21 brings evaluation and reporting duties, and the clause must go into your own orders
Which line items are safety-related and which are notApplying the full programme to every item raises cost; applying it to too few is a nonconformance
Whether the purchaser must audit and approve your programme before award or before work startsThe audit date can set the schedule
Flow-down: what your sub-suppliers' orders must contain, and whether the purchaser approves sub-suppliersSub-suppliers that refuse nuclear clauses force a change of source or commercial grade dedication
Right of access for the purchaser, its customer and the regulator, at your works and your sub-suppliers'You can only grant access you have secured in your own orders
Documents to submit for approval before use: quality plan, ITP, procedures, personnel qualificationsWork started on an unapproved procedure may need repeating
Hold and witness points, and the notice periodA missed hold point is a nonconformance even if the result is good
Material requirements: source, certified material test reports, traceability and markingThey must go into the material order on day one
Qualification of special process, inspection and test personnelThe standard the certificates must meet is set by the order
Calibration requirements, including traceability of standards and accreditation of laboratoriesA calibration supplier may itself need qualifying
Nonconformance rules: which dispositions need purchaser approval"Use as is" and "repair" usually need it in writing
Records: the list to deliver, the format, and how long you keep your copiesRetention periods can run for the life of the plant
Controls against counterfeit, fraudulent and suspect itemsThey affect how you buy from distributors
Software used for design, analysis or acceptanceSoftware that supports a safety-related decision may itself fall under the programme

OdysseyGPT's Document Review compares a purchaser's quality requirements with your own quality manual extract or standard quality plan, and drafts a compliance matrix and a list of exceptions with both texts quoted. Customer Specification Review (beta) lists the requirements one by one. After award, the ITP Validator (beta) checks a quality plan or ITP against those requirements, and the MRB Readiness Check (beta) compares the record folder with the purchaser's index.

What OdysseyGPT does not do

It does not audit, approve or certify a quality assurance programme, and it does not decide whether your programme meets NQA-1. It is not software qualified under a nuclear quality programme. It reads the documents you give it and quotes the source of each finding. People qualified under your own programme must verify the output before relying on it.

Talk through your tender review

See how OdysseyGPT reviews a tender

Tell us how your team reviews tenders today. We can walk through an example together.

Book a call

Frequently asked questions

What is NQA-1?

ASME NQA-1 is a standard of quality assurance requirements for nuclear facility applications. It sets out what an organisation's quality programme must control, in eighteen requirement areas, when its work affects a nuclear facility.

What are the 18 requirements of NQA-1?

Organization; quality assurance program; design control; procurement document control; instructions, procedures and drawings; document control; control of purchased items and services; identification and control of items; special processes; inspection; test control; measuring and test equipment; handling, storage and shipping; inspection, test and operating status; nonconforming items; corrective action; records; and audits.

Is NQA-1 the same as 10 CFR 50 Appendix B?

No. Appendix B is a US regulation with eighteen quality assurance criteria. NQA-1 is an ASME standard with eighteen matching requirements and more detail. The US regulator accepts named editions of NQA-1, with conditions, as a way to meet Appendix B.

Which edition of NQA-1 should a supplier use?

The one the purchase order names. The plant's licensing basis fixes the edition, and the purchaser passes it down. If the order is silent, ask before you sign.

Is NQA-1 the same as ISO 9001?

No. Both are quality management standards, but NQA-1 is written for nuclear facility work and is more prescriptive on matters such as procurement, inspection, nonconformances and records. An ISO 9001 certificate does not answer a requirement for an NQA-1 programme.

References

NQA-1: Quality Assurance Requirements for Nuclear Facility Applications

ASME

Paid standard. Scope from the public product page.

Visit source

Nuclear Quality Assurance (NQA-1) Certification

ASME

Visit source

Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50: Quality Assurance Criteria for Nuclear Power Plants and Fuel Reprocessing Plants

US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (eCFR)

Visit source

Regulatory Guide 1.28, Revision 6: Quality Assurance Program Criteria (Design and Construction)

US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Visit source

10 CFR Part 21: Reporting of Defects and Noncompliance

US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (eCFR)

Visit source

ASME NQA

Wikipedia

Used for the structure of the parts, the requirement titles and the edition history.

Visit source

Related Pages