Download the order acknowledgement checklist
XLSX
Order acknowledgement and contract review checklist (Excel)
Header block, 9 columns, drop-downs for area and result, Differs and New in PO rows in red, Missing from PO and Query rows in amber, frozen header row, filters and a How to use sheet.
CSV
Order acknowledgement and contract review checklist (CSV)
The example rows as plain CSV (UTF-8), for Google Sheets or any other tool.
Both files are free under CC BY 4.0, with no form to fill in. The XLSX opens in Excel, Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. The CSV carries the table only; the header block is in the XLSX.
What it is for and who uses it
A purchase order often differs from the quotation it follows: a newer specification revision, an agreed deviation left out, a shorter delivery, different payment terms. Contract review is the check that finds those differences before you commit to the order. Quality management standards such as ISO 9001 ask for a review of requirements before a supplier commits to supply. For the method, see purchase order vs quotation review.
- Order engineers and project engineers, who compare the technical content.
- Sales and contracts managers, who own price and terms.
- Project managers, who own the delivery date and send the acknowledgement.
This checklist records the comparison. It is not legal advice. What an acknowledgement commits you to depends on the contract and the law that governs it, so check the contract and ask for legal advice where it is unclear.
Header block
| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| Customer | Example EPC Contractor Ltd (fictional) |
| Project | Example Gas Compression Station, Phase 2 (fictional) |
| Purchase order / revision | PO-EX-3105 Rev 0 (fictional) |
| PO date / date received | 2026-10-12 / 2026-10-13 |
| Quotation / revision | OF-EX-2291 Rev C, dated 2026-09-29 |
| Agreed deviation list | TDL-EX-2291 Rev B |
| Acknowledgement due | 2026-10-20 (PO clause 2) |
| Checklist no. | CRC-EX-3105 |
| Prepared by | Order engineer |
| Reviewed by | Sales manager |
| Decision | Acknowledge with listed exceptions; PO revision requested |
Example rows: purchase order PO-EX-3105 against the quotation
| Item | Area | Check | Quotation says | Purchase order says | Result | Action before acknowledgement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scope | Items, tags and quantities | Line 1: 6 ea 6 in trunnion ball valves. Line 2: 4 ea 2 in floating ball valves. Line 5: commissioning spares | Lines 1, 2 and 5 as quoted | Match | None. |
| 2 | Scope | Anything ordered that was not quoted as part of the order | Two-year operating spares: priced list only, not in the order value | Line 6 orders the two-year spares as one lot, no price stated | New in PO | Ask for a PO revision that states the spares list and price, or remove line 6. |
| 3 | Technical | Specification and datasheet revisions | PS-VAL-001 Rev 2; DS-VAL-0600 Rev B | PS-VAL-001 Rev 3; DS-VAL-0600 Rev B | Differs | Request Rev 3 and review the changes before acknowledging. State any cost or schedule effect. |
| 4 | Technical | Agreed deviations and clarifications carried into the PO | TDL-EX-2291 Rev B, including EX-03 (RPTFE seats) and EX-08 (tests to API 6D) | Cites TDL-EX-2291 Rev A | Differs | Ask the customer to cite Rev B. List it as an exception until the PO is revised. |
| 5 | Technical | Size, rating, materials and end connections | As DS-VAL-0600 Rev B and DS-VAL-0200 Rev A | As quoted | Match | None. |
| 6 | Documents | Vendor data requirements list: revision and first submission dates | VDRL-VAL-001 Rev 1; first submission 4 weeks after order | VDRL-VAL-001 Rev 1; first submission 2 weeks after order | Differs | List as an exception: 4 weeks, as quoted. |
| 7 | Documents | Material certificate type | EN 10204 type 3.2 for pressure-containing parts; inspector fees by the buyer | Type 3.2; inspector not named | Query | Ask who the nominated inspector is and confirm fees are by the buyer. |
| 8 | Inspection | Hold and witness points and notice period | Pressure tests witnessed by the customer; 10 working days' notice | Adds a third-party inspector at final inspection | Differs | Accept, and add the point to the ITP. Confirm the third party is paid by the customer. |
| 9 | Delivery | Delivery date and Incoterms | 26 weeks after order, FCA supplier works | 2027-03-29 (24 weeks after the PO date), FCA supplier works | Differs | List as an exception: 26 weeks, or agree what makes 24 weeks possible. |
| 10 | Delivery | Liquidated damages for late delivery | 0.5% per week, capped at 5% | 1% per week, capped at 10% | Differs | Refer to the contracts manager before acknowledging. |
| 11 | Price | Unit prices, currency and total | USD, as the commercial offer | As quoted for lines 1, 2 and 5 | Match | None. |
| 12 | Terms | Payment terms | 30% with order, 70% on delivery | 100% 60 days after delivery | Differs | Refer to the finance manager. List as an exception until agreed. |
| 13 | Terms | Quotation still valid on the PO date | Valid for 90 days from 2026-09-29 | PO dated 2026-10-12 | Match | None. |
| 14 | Terms | Governing conditions and order of precedence | Customer's general conditions with the exceptions listed in the commercial offer | Customer's general conditions; the exceptions are not mentioned | Missing from PO | Ask for the agreed exceptions to be cited in the PO. |
| 15 | Capability | Long-lead material and sub-supplier quotations still valid for the PO delivery date | Forging quotation valid to 2026-10-30 | Delivery 2027-03-29 | Query | Reconfirm the forging lead time before you acknowledge a delivery date. |
The file also has Owner and Remarks columns. Row 3 shows a specification revision that changed between quotation and order, and row 4 an agreed deviation list cited at the wrong revision. Every example value is invented: the project, customer, bidders, purchase order, prices and every document, certificate, serial and report number do not exist. Standards are named but not quoted.
Columns and what to write
| Column | What to write |
|---|---|
| Item | Running number. |
| Area | Scope, Technical, Documents, Inspection, Delivery, Price, Terms or Capability (drop-down). |
| Check | What you compare between the quotation and the purchase order. |
| Quotation says | What your final quotation and agreed deviation list state, with the section or line. |
| Purchase order says | What the purchase order and the documents it cites state, with the clause or line. |
| Result | Match, Differs, New in PO, Missing from PO or Query (drop-down). Differs and New in PO rows turn red; Missing from PO and Query rows amber. |
| Action before acknowledgement | What you will do: accept, list as an exception in the acknowledgement, or ask for a PO revision. |
| Owner | Who closes the item. |
| Remarks | Cost or schedule effect, or the customer's answer. |
Result values
| Result | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Match | The purchase order says what the quotation says. Nothing to do. |
| Differs | Both documents cover the point, but they say different things. |
| New in PO | The purchase order asks for something the quotation did not offer. |
| Missing from PO | The quotation states something the purchase order leaves out, such as an agreed deviation or exception. |
| Query | You cannot tell from the documents. Ask the customer before you acknowledge. |
How to use the template
- Fill in the header block: the purchase order and its revision, the final quotation and agreed deviation list it should reflect, and the date the acknowledgement is due.
- Collect every document the purchase order cites, at the revision it cites. A newer specification or datasheet revision is a change, even if the PO text looks the same.
- Go through the rows area by area: scope, technical, documents, inspection, delivery, price, terms and your own capability to deliver. Add rows for anything else the PO contains.
- For each row, write what the quotation says and what the purchase order says, with the clause or line, and set the result.
- Give every row that is not Match an action and an owner: accept it, list it as an exception in the acknowledgement, or ask for a PO revision.
- Have the people who own price, terms and delivery review their rows. Record the decision in the header.
- Acknowledge the order in writing, listing every exception, and keep this checklist with the order file. What an acknowledgement commits you to depends on the contract; check it, and ask for legal advice where it is unclear.
Comparing the PO and the quotation from the documents
In OdysseyGPT's Order & Document Control module, Quotation-to-PO Review (beta) reads the quotation and the purchase order and lists what changed between them. Every finding cites the page it came from, and your engineers decide what to do with it. Tools marked beta are open on request, and we onboard each team ourselves. For what happens after the order is accepted, see order engineering.
Want us to run the check for you?
Send your quotation and the customer's purchase order. We send back a list of what changed between them, each item cited to its page.
